Operationalising the context in regenerative agriculture: decision-making and farm variability
Preprint
Abstract
Soil degradation is a widespread challenge that requires a broad response at the individual farm level. To ensure effectivity, the practices should be tailored to the farm context: land manager objectives and farm specific challenges. These have however been difficult to quantify. Here we demonstrate that a workable farm context can be created based on a value survey, open satellite and soil data, and published models for vegetation gross primary productivity and soil erosion. Based on the findings, despite individual differences, farmers value profitability and operational efficiency, but also biodiversity and soil health. At least the regenerative farmers surveyed also value working for the greater good more than maintaining tradition or power. In spite of wide differences in farm production orientation, we also found that each farm also had a broad variation in individual fields GPP. Most fields have a stable GPP level, which is either high or low, and that there is a 2–3-fold difference between the weakest and best producing fields indicating the potential for improving GPP by improving the growing conditions on currently weak fields. In addition, soil loss was found to be highly concentrated in critical source areas, where 10% of the field area contributed to 50% of the soil loss. Overall, open data can be linked to modelling workflows to rapidly produce a decision-making context for farmers. This facilitates benchmarking and co-learning as well as enables land managers and advisors to identify the farm context for planning effective responses to soil degradation.Keywords
This publication has 31 references indexed in Scilit:
- Targeting phosphorus loss with carbon farming practices? Results from an on‐farm studyJournal of Environmental Quality, 2026
- Grass leys as a multifunctional climate mitigation strategy in intensive cropping systems: Balancing environmental benefits and economic barriersAgriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 2026
- Selecting performance indicators for farms and ranches engaged in collaborative agroecosystem researchJournal of Environmental Quality, 2025
- A Soil Monitoring Law for EuropeGlobal Challenges, 2025
- Exploring the RUSLE-based structural sediment connectivity approach for agricultural erosion managementCATENA, 2024
- Agricultural limitations to soil carbon sequestration: Plant growth, microbial activity, and carbon stabilizationAgriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 2024
- A review of the development and implementation of the critical source area concept: A reflection of Andrew Sharpley's role in improving water qualityJournal of Environmental Quality, 2024
- How to make regenerative practices work on the farm: A modelling frameworkAgricultural Systems, 2022
- Value priorities of the Finnish farmers—Time to stop thinking of farmers as inherently conservative and traditionalJournal of Community & Applied Social Psychology, 2021
- Unexploited potential to diversify monotonous crop sequencing at high latitudesAgricultural Systems, 2019