Evaluating the Economic Efficiency of Fuel Reduction Treatments in Sagebrush Ecosystems That Vary in Ecological Resilience and Invasion Resistance
Open Access
Abstract
The concepts of resilience and resistance (R&R) have been used to improve wildland fuel treatment outcomes by identifying parts of the landscape that are more likely to respond well to treatment. This study examined how the economic benefits and costs of fuel treatments in sagebrush (Artemisia spp.) ecosystems varied with the resilience and resistance properties of the treatment site. Generalized ecological models were developed for the economic analysis of fuel treatments that integrated ecological succession, annual grass invasion, pinyon–juniper expansion, and wildfire to simulate ecosystem dynamics over time. The models incorporated resilience and resistance by varying model parameters related to each plant community’s ability to resist annual grass invasion and recover post-disturbance. Simulations produced estimates of the expected (ex ante) benefit–cost ratio for each treatment. The approach also considered the benefits associated with the system remaining in an ecologically favorable condition, allowing us to report a more holistic measure of the net economic benefits of fuel treatments. The results from the simulations indicated fuel treatment was economically efficient in late-successional sagebrush and early-successional juniper in mountain big sagebrush associations. For sagebrush associations where treatment was economically efficient, higher R&R status sites had higher benefit–cost ratios. The results suggested that treatment costs were more determinative of economic efficiency than treatment benefits.Keywords
Funding Information
- Joint Fire Science Program (19-2-02-11)
- USDA Forest Service, Rocky Mountain Research Station (19-2-02-11)
This publication has 34 references indexed in Scilit:
- Ecologically relevant moisture and temperature metrics for assessing dryland ecosystem dynamicsEcohydrology, 2022
- Fuel reduction treatments reduce modeled fire intensity in the sagebrush steppeEcosphere, 2022
- The elevational ascent and spread of exotic annual grass dominance in the Great Basin, USADiversity and Distributions, 2021
- Threat‐Based State and Transition Models Predict Sage‐Grouse Occurrence while Promoting Landscape ConservationWildlife Society Bulletin, 2021
- Living with exotic annual grasses in the sagebrush ecosystemJournal of Environmental Management, 2021
- Improving Landsat predictions of rangeland fractional cover with multitask learning and uncertaintyMethods in Ecology and Evolution, 2021
- Cheatgrass (Bromus tectorum) distribution in the intermountain Western United States and its relationship to fire frequency, seasonality, and ignitionsBiological Invasions, 2017
- Cheatgrass Percent Cover Change: Comparing Recent Estimates to Climate Change−Driven Predictions in the Northern Great BasinRangeland Ecology & Management, 2016
- The economics of fuel management: Wildfire, invasive plants, and the dynamics of sagebrush rangelands in the western United StatesJournal of Environmental Management, 2013
- Estimating Suppression Expenditures for Individual Large Wildland FiresWestern Journal of Applied Forestry, 2007