Comparison of Two Types of Metapopulation Models in Real and Artificial Landscapes
Authors:
- 3 August 2001
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Conservation Biology
- Vol. 15 (4) , 1102-1113
Abstract
Application of metapopulation models is becoming increasingly widespread in the conservation of species in fragmented landscapes. We provide one of the first detailed comparisons of two of the most common modeling techniques, incidence function models and stage‐based matrix models, and test their accuracy in predicting patch occupancy for a real metapopulation. We measured patch occupancies and demographic rates for regional populations of the Florida scrub lizard ( Sceloporus woodi ) and compared the observed occupancies with those predicted by each model. Both modeling strategies predicted patch occupancies with good accuracy ( 77–80%) and gave similar results when we compared hypothetical management scenarios involving removal of key habitat patches and degradation of habitat quality. To compare the two modeling approaches over a broader set of conditions, we simulated metapopulation dynamics for 150 artificial landscapes composed of equal‐sized patches (2–1024 ha) spaced at equal distances (50–750 m). Differences in predicted patch occupancy were small to moderate ( 50%. Incidence function models and stage‐based matrix models differ in their approaches, assumptions, and requirements for empirical data, and our findings provide evidence that the two models can produce different results. We encourage researchers to use both techniques and further examine potential differences in model output. The feasibility of obtaining data for population modeling varies widely among species and limits the modeling approaches appropriate for each species. Understanding different modeling approaches will become increasingly important as conservation programs undertake the challenge of managing for multiple species in a landscape context.Keywords
This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- Use of Population Viability Analysis to Evaluate Management Options for the Endangered Lower Keys Marsh RabbitThe Journal of Wildlife Management, 1999
- On the Use of Demographic Models of Population Viability in Endangered Species ManagementThe Journal of Wildlife Management, 1998
- Population Viability Analysis of the Florida Manatee ( Trichechus manatus latirostris ), 1976–1991Conservation Biology, 1997
- Modeling Extinction in Periodic Environments: Everglades Water Levels and Snail Kite Population ViabilityEcological Applications, 1995
- Parameter Estimation, Reliability, and Model Improvement for Spatially Explicit Models of Animal PopulationsEcological Applications, 1995
- Usefulness of Spatially Explicit Population Models in Land ManagementEcological Applications, 1995
- Spotted Owl Metapopulation Dynamics in Southern CaliforniaJournal of Animal Ecology, 1994
- A Practical Model of Metapopulation DynamicsJournal of Animal Ecology, 1994
- A Dynamic Analysis of Northern Spotted Owl Viability in a Fragmented Forest Landscape*Conservation Biology, 1992
- PrefaceBiological Journal of the Linnean Society, 1991