Experience, Time Investment, and Motivators of Nursing Journal Peer Reviewers
Authors:
- Margaret H. KearneyMKMargaret H. Kearney
- Judith G. BaggsJBJudith G. Baggs
- Marion E. BroomeMBMarion E. Broome
- Molly C. DoughertyMDMolly C. Dougherty
- Margaret C. FredaMFMargaret C. Freda
- 25 November 2008
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Nursing Scholarship
- Vol. 40 (4) , 395-400
Abstract
Purpose: To describe nursing journal reviewers' professional backgrounds, reviewing experience, time investment, and perceptions of their role. Design: Exploratory descriptive cross‐sectional study. Methods: A 69‐question survey containing both fixed‐option and open‐ended questions and accessed via the World Wide Web was completed by 1,675 nursing journal reviewers who had been invited to participate by editors of 52 nursing journals. Findings: Participants were from 44 countries, with 74% from the US, and 90% were nurses. The majority were doctorally prepared academics who were involved in research. They reported spending an average of 5 hours on each critique and completed an average of 7–8 reviews per year. The most common reason reported for becoming involved was personal contact with an editor. Lack of time because of competing work commitments was the most commonly cited barrier to reviewing and negative aspect of the role. The most common positive aspect was keeping up to date with the field. Conclusions: Nursing journal peer reviewers express rewards and challenges similar to those reported elsewhere for biomedical journal reviewers. Based on these findings, editors might consider new approaches to recruiting and supporting reviewers, and potential reviewers might gain insight into the role. Support of these distinguished scholars in this important role is critical to sustain the quality of scholarship that informs nursing practice, education, and research. Clinical Relevance: Clinicians, researchers, and educators who rely on the quality of the articles published in nursing journals can learn from this survey about the background and experiences of those who protect that quality by providing expert feedback to authors and editors.Keywords
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- Disease topics that define the Annals of Neurology: IntrospectionAnnals of Neurology, 2007
- Early editorial manuscript screening versus obligate peer review: A randomized trialAnnals of Neurology, 2007
- Statistical Reviewers Improve Reporting in Biomedical Articles: A Randomized TrialPLOS ONE, 2007
- The Relationship of Previous Training and Experience of Journal Peer Reviewers to Subsequent Review QualityPLOS Medicine, 2007
- Why do peer reviewers decline to review? A surveyJournal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 2006
- Reviewing the Reviewers: Comparison of Review Quality and Reviewer Characteristics at the American Journal of RoentgenologyAmerican Journal of Roentgenology, 2005
- An International Survey of Nurse Editors' Roles and PracticesJournal of Nursing Scholarship, 2005
- Reviewers' perceptions of the peer review process for a medical education journalMedical Education, 2004
- The use of dedicated methodology and statistical reviewers for peer review: A content analysis of comments to authors made by methodology and regular reviewersAnnals of Emergency Medicine, 2002
- Nursing Publications Outside the United StatesJournal of Nursing Scholarship, 2000