Toward Empathic Agonism: Conflicting Vulnerabilities in Urban Wetland Governance
- 1 January 2013
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space
- Vol. 45 (10) , 2344-2361
Abstract
Critics of attempts to achieve consensus through Habermasian ‘communicative rationality’ dismiss this as unachievable due to participants' selfishness and irrationality, and the inevitability of power relations. Instead, Mouffe advocates ‘agonistic pluralism’, a dynamic process of continual debate grounded in mutual respect. In this paper I argue that, for this to succeed, we need to recognize and embrace the role of emotion in moral reasoning. Here, I examine a dispute over wetland management in suburban New Jersey. Each side articulated distinct understandings of what was and was not vulnerable, backed by emotional appeals partly based in self-interest but that also encompassed care and concern for others. Each side accused the other of being irrational and immoral, drawing ‘moral microboundaries’ between them. I conclude that participants in a public debate may not simply be pursing self-serving goals, nor might open communication resolve their differences. Instead, each may be deeply convinced that he or she is advocating the most rational and moral course of action. This questions the very notion of a unitary, potentially agreed-upon ‘common good’ and instead challenges us to attempt to grasp each other's moral worlds, and in particular the emotional bases of these, through the seeming oxymoron that I term ‘empathic agonism’.Keywords
This publication has 33 references indexed in Scilit:
- Anthropomorphism as a conservation toolBiodiversity and Conservation, 2012
- The Social Dynamics and Durability of Moral Boundaries1Sociological Forum, 2009
- SPECIESISM AND MORAL STATUSMetaphilosophy, 2009
- The Impact of Emotional Opportunities on the Emotion Cultures of Feminist OrganizationsGender & Society, 2009
- The Study of Boundaries in the Social SciencesAnnual Review of Sociology, 2002
- Resisting the Discourse of Modernity: Rationality Versus Emotion in Hazardous Waste SitingHuman Relations, 2000
- Deconstructing Communicative Rationality: A Critique of Habermasian Collaborative PlanningEnvironment and Planning A: Economy and Space, 1998
- Habermas and Foucault: Thinkers for Civil Society?The British Journal of Sociology, 1998
- Support for environmental protection: The role of moral normsPopulation and Environment, 1985
- Boundary-Work and the Demarcation of Science from Non-Science: Strains and Interests in Professional Ideologies of ScientistsAmerican Sociological Review, 1983