One Score Fits All? A Narrative Review on Early Warning Scores for Older Adults in the Emergency Department in the Era of Personalized Medicine
Authors:
- Valeria MaccauroVMValeria Maccauro
- Piergiacomo Maria Cacciamani FanelliPiergiacomo Maria Cacciamani Fanelli
- Davide Antonio Della PollaDavide Antonio Della Polla
- Nicola BonadiaNBNicola Bonadia
- Giuseppe De MatteisGMGiuseppe De Matteis
- Andrea PiccioniAndrea Piccioni
- Antonio GasbarriniAntonio Gasbarrini
- Claudio SandroniCSClaudio Sandroni
- Francesco FranceschiFFFrancesco Franceschi
- Marcello CovinoMarcello Covino
Open Access
- 6 February 2026
- journal article
- review article
- Published by MDPI AG in Journal of Personalized Medicine
- Vol. 16 (2) , 98
Abstract
Background: The growing use of Emergency Departments (EDs) by older adults highlights the need for early and accurate identification of clinical deterioration. Early Warning Scores (EWSs) are widely implemented tools based on standardized vital sign thresholds; however, their performance in elderly patients is inconsistent, likely reflecting the biological heterogeneity, multimorbidity, and reduced physiological reserve typical of this population. Objectives: This narrative review aims to summarize current evidence on the use of EWSs in adults aged ≥ 65 years presenting to the ED, with a specific focus on mortality and intensive care unit (ICU) admission, and to discuss their role within the evolving framework of personalized medicine. Sources: A narrative review of 36 clinical studies published between 2014 and 2025 was conducted. Content: Traditional scores such as National Early Warning Score (NEWS), National Early Warning Score 2 (NEWS2), Modified Early Warning Score (MEWS), VitalPAC Early Warning Score (ViEWS), Rapid Acute Physiology Score (RAPS) and Rapid Emergency Medicine Score (REMS) show variable and often reduced prognostic accuracy in older and frail patients. Evidence consistently suggests that applying uniform cut-off values fails to capture individual vulnerability in elderly patients. The integration of age, frailty, comorbidities, and baseline physiological status improves risk stratification. Second-generation tools—including Copeptin-NEWS, NEWS-L, suPAR-NEWS, OPERA, and RISE UP—as well as artificial intelligence-based models, represent emerging personalized approaches to clinical deterioration prediction. Implications: No single score currently provides reliable early risk prediction for all elderly ED patients. Moving beyond “one-size-fits-all” EWSs toward adaptive, person-centered models may better reflect the complexity of geriatric emergency care and improve prognostic accuracy.Keywords
This publication has 98 references indexed in Scilit:
- Early Warning Scores With and Without Artificial IntelligenceJAMA Network Open, 2024
- Effectiveness of an Artificial Intelligence–Enabled Intervention for Detecting Clinical DeteriorationJAMA Internal Medicine, 2024
- Prevalence of Frailty in European Emergency Departments (FEED): an international flash mob studyEuropean Geriatric Medicine, 2024
- The effect of relative hypotension on 30-day mortality in older people receiving emergency careInternal and Emergency Medicine, 2023
- The predictive value of modified soluble urokinase plasminogen activator receptor (suPAR) with National Early Warning Score (NEWS) for mortality in emergency elderly patients in Japan: a prospective pilot studyAcute Medicine & Surgery, 2023
- Comparison of national early warning score-2 and qSOFA in predicting the prognosis of older adults with altered mental statusIrish Journal of Medical Science (1971 -), 2022
- Prevalence and clinical significance of point of care elevated lactate at emergency admission in older patients: a prospective studyInternal and Emergency Medicine, 2022
- Dynamic data in the ED predict requirement for ICU transfer following acute care admissionJournal of Clinical Monitoring and Computing, 2020
- The predictive value of the modified early warning score with rapid lactate level (ViEWS-L) for mortality in patients of age 65 or older visiting the emergency departmentInternal and Emergency Medicine, 2016
- Comparison of the National Early Warning Score in non-elective medical and surgical patientsBritish Journal of Surgery, 2016