On the choice of methodology for evaluating dose-rate effects on radiation-related cancer risks
Open Access
- 25 June 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Radiation and Environmental Biophysics
- Vol. 60 (3) , 493-500
Abstract
Recently, several compilations of individual radiation epidemiology study results have aimed to obtain direct evidence on the magnitudes of dose-rate effects on radiation-related cancer risks. These compilations have relied on meta-analyses of ratios of risks from low dose-rate studies and matched risks from the solid cancer Excess Relative Risk models fitted to the acutely exposed Japanese A-bomb cohort. The purpose here is to demonstrate how choices of methodology for evaluating dose-rate effects on radiation-related cancer risks may influence the results reported for dose-rate effects. The current analysis is intended to address methodological issues and does not imply that the authors recommend a particular value for the dose and dose-rate effectiveness factor. A set of 22 results from one recent published study has been adopted here as a test set of data for applying the many different methods described here, that nearly all produced highly consistent results. Some recently voiced concerns, involving the recalling of the well-known theoretical point—the ratio of two normal random variables has a theoretically unbounded variance—that could potentially cause issues, are shown to be unfounded when aimed at the published work cited and examined in detail here. In the calculation of dose-rate effects for radiation protection purposes, it is recommended that meta-estimators should retain the full epidemiological and dosimetric matching information between the risks from the individual low dose-rate studies and the acutely exposed A-bomb cohort and that a regression approach can be considered as a useful alternative to current approaches.Keywords
Funding Information
- Universität Zürich
This publication has 48 references indexed in Scilit:
- Mortality (1950–1999) and cancer incidence (1969–1999) of workers in the Port Hope cohort study exposed to a unique combination of radium, uranium and γ-ray dosesBMJ Open, 2013
- Solid Cancer Mortality in the Techa River Cohort (1950–2007)Radiation Research, 2013
- Cancer and non-cancer mortality among Inhabitants in the High Background Radiation Area of Yangjiang, China (1979–1998)Health Physics, 2012
- Updated Mortality Analysis of Radiation Workers at Rocketdyne (Atomics International), 1948–2008Radiation Research, 2011
- Is cancer risk of radiation workers larger than expected?Occupational and Environmental Medicine, 2009
- Recent developments in meta‐analysisStatistics in Medicine, 2007
- Mortality rates among nuclear industry workers at Lucas Heights Science and Technology CentreAustralian and New Zealand Journal of Public Health, 2005
- Cancer Incidence Among Finnish Nuclear Reactor WorkersJournal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine, 2002
- Meta-analysis in clinical trialsControlled Clinical Trials, 1986
- Parametric Empirical Bayes Inference: Theory and ApplicationsJournal of the American Statistical Association, 1983