Charting how landscape interventions reshape production–nature trade-offs across contrasting agricultural contexts

Authors:

Abstract
Agricultural systems are increasingly expected to sustain production while enhancing ecosystem services and conservation, yet still few studies assess how different farming interventions influence these three outcomes considering context-dependency at the same time. We charted a conceptual causal network to integrate the effects of multiple landscape interventions on ecological processes, ecosystem services, conservation and production across six contrasting agricultural contexts of the Argentine Chaco-Pampean region, a grain belt of global relevance. The network was constructed through an iterative expert elicitation process and links management decisions with soil, water and biodiversity processes and their outcomes. Our analysis showed that individual interventions affect multiple processes simultaneously, often through opposing pathways that generate context-dependent trade-offs and synergies among production, ecosystem services and conservation. Service crops can increase soil organic carbon, water infiltration and pest regulation, but may reduce production under dry conditions due to resource competition. Similarly, the incorporation of natural and seminatural elements enhances ecosystem services such as hydrological and greenhouse gas balance regulation, pest control, pollination, while strengthening conservation outcomes through biodiversity-mediated mechanisms. These benefits are weaker in drier contexts. Across contexts, trade-offs between production, ecosystem services and conservation shift with soil texture, slope and rainfall regimes. Conventional systems maximizing cropped area increase short-term production but weaken ecosystem services and conservation, compromising the long-term sustainability of production as well. By explicitly linking interventions to processes, this framework reveals how context shapes the balance among production, ecosystem services and conservation in landscapes where production coexists with nature, and provides a tool to design multifunctional agricultural landscapes under diverse environmental conditions.

This publication has 68 references indexed in Scilit: