Random error reduction in analytic hierarchies: a comparison of holistic and decompositional decision strategies
Authors:
- Osvaldo F. MoreraOMOsvaldo F. Morera
- David V. BudescuDBDavid V. Budescu
- 29 June 2001
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Behavioral Decision Making
- Vol. 14 (3) , 223-242
Abstract
The principle of ‘divide and conquer’ (DAC) suggests that complex decision problems should be decomposed into smaller, more manageable parts, and that these parts should be logically aggregated to derive an overall value for each alternative. Decompositional procedures have been contrasted with holistic evaluations that require decision makers to simultaneously consider all the relevant attributes of the alternatives under consideration (Fischer, 1977). One area where decompositional procedures have a clear advantage over holistic procedures is in the reduction of random error (Ravinder, 1992; Ravinder and Kleinmuntz, 1991; Kleinmuntz, 1990). Adopting the framework originally developed by Ravinder and colleagues, this paper details the results of a study of the random error variances associated with another popular multi‐criteria decision‐making technique, the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP); (Saaty, 1977, 1980), as well as the random error variances of a holistic version of the Analytic Hierarchy Process (Jensen, 1983). In addition, data concerning various psychometric properties (e.g. the convergent validity and temporal stability) and values of AHP inconsistency are reported for both the decompositional and holistic evaluations. The results of the study show that the Ravinder and Kleinmuntz (1991) error‐propagation framework extends to the AHP and decompositional AHP judgments are more consistent than their holistic counterparts. Copyright © 2001 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.Keywords
This publication has 45 references indexed in Scilit:
- Attribute Range and Response Range: Limits of Compatibility in Multiattribute JudgmentOrganizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 1995
- Range Sensitivity of Attribute Weights in Multiattribute Value ModelsOrganizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 1995
- SMARTS and SMARTER: Improved Simple Methods for Multiattribute Utility MeasurementOrganizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 1994
- Random error in additive decompositions of multiattribute utilityJournal of Behavioral Decision Making, 1991
- RANK GENERATION, PRESERVATION, AND REVERSAL IN THE ANALYTIC HIERARCHY DECISION PROCESSDecision Sciences, 1987
- A comparison of holistic and decomposed judgment strategies in a performance rating simulationOrganizational Behavior and Human Performance, 1982
- A comparison of holistic and decomposed judgment strategies in job analyses by job incumbents.Journal of Applied Psychology, 1980
- A scaling method for priorities in hierarchical structuresJournal of Mathematical Psychology, 1977
- Convergent validation of decomposed multi-attribute utility assessment procedures for risky and riskless decisionsOrganizational Behavior and Human Performance, 1977
- Comparison of Bayesian and regression approaches to the study of information processing in judgmentOrganizational Behavior and Human Performance, 1971