Double Counting, Moral Rigorism, and Cohen’s Critique of Rawls: A Response to Alan Thomas
Author:
- 13 June 2015
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Mind
- Vol. 124 (495) , 849-874
Abstract
In a recent article in this journal, Alan Thomas presents a novel defence of what I call ‘Rawlsian Institutionalism about Justice’ against G. A. Cohen’s well-known critique. In this response I aim to defend Cohen’s rejection of Institutionalism against Thomas’s arguments. In part this defence requires clarifying precisely what is at issue between Institutionalists and their opponents. My primary focus, however, is on Thomas’s critical discussion of Cohen’s endorsement of an ethical prerogative, as well as his appeal to the institutional framework of a ‘property-owning democracy’ in his elaboration of the precise institutional requirements of Rawlsian Institutionalist justice, and his related claim that Cohen’s rejection of Institutionalism involves an objectionable ‘double counting’ of the demands of justice. I argue that once we are clear about both the kind of justification that can be given for a prerogative within a plausible ethical theory, and about the key points of departure between Institutionalist views and their rivals, Cohen’s rejection of Institutionalism appears well-motivated, and Thomas’s claim that his view is guilty of double counting the demands of justice can be seen to be mistaken.Keywords
This publication has 17 references indexed in Scilit:
- Productive JusticePhilosophy & Public Affairs, 2012
- Cohen's Critique of Rawls: A Double Counting ObjectionMind, 2011
- I—Samuel Scheffler: Egalitarian Liberalism as Moral PluralismAristotelian Society Supplementary Volume, 2005
- Justice and personal pursuitsThe Journal of Philosophy, 2004
- Taking People as They Are?Philosophy & Public Affairs, 2001
- On the Site of Distributive Justice: Reflections on Cohen and MurphyPhilosophy & Public Affairs, 2000
- Institutions and the Demands of JusticePhilosophy & Public Affairs, 1998
- Incentives, Inequality, and PublicityPhilosophy & Public Affairs, 1998
- Debate: Liberalism, Equality, and Fraternity in Cohen’s Critique of RawlsJournal of Political Philosophy, 1998
- Incentives and JusticeSocial Theory and Practice, 1998