Recruitment of nursing homes and residents in a cluster-randomised controlled trial to improve oral health (MundZaRR): a structured analysis of trials and tribulations
Open Access
- 13 March 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Trials
- Vol. 27 (1)
Abstract
Background: The cluster-randomised controlled MundZaRR trial aimed to improve the oral health of nursing home (NH) residents through a complex intervention programme. Recruitment in NH settings is notably challenging. Since there is only a limited number of reports from comparable studies on recruitment, we aimed to analyse the challenges and barriers related to the recruitment process of MundZaRR. Methods: NHs in Southwestern Germany were recruited by the study team, and residents via NH contact persons, e.g. NH managers. We aimed for 618 recruited residents from 18 NHs. Due to two COVID-19 pandemic-related interruptions, recruitment occurred in three phases from September 2019 until June 2022. The recruitment strategies had to be adapted during the course of the pandemic (e.g. from face-to-face to email/telephone contact). The recruitment process was continuously documented and analysed descriptively. Results: A total of 111 NHs were deemed eligible, and finally 18 NHs agreed to participate (participation rate: 16%). Overall, 358 individual consents were obtained, n = 89 (25%) from residents and n = 269 (75%) from their representatives, resulting in an average participation rate (corresponding to the NHs’ total number of beds) of 27% (min = 10%, max = 85%). Major challenges were the withdrawal of eight clusters (with n = 87 residents) from the first recruitment phase and the high number of residents who deceased during the recruitment process ( n = 75). The COVID-19 pandemic, associated with time constraints and staff shortages at the NHs, was another significant barrier. At the individual level, obtaining informed consent from residents’ representatives was particularly challenging. Conclusion: Despite using various strategies and intensive efforts, we achieved the planned number of clusters, but failed to reach the targeted sample size of residents. The pandemic-related measures and negative effects as well as the process of obtaining consent from residents’ representatives were major challenges. Personal contact with NHs and flexible approaches for reaching residents’ representatives seem to be important strategies. However, future cluster-randomised studies with comparable vulnerable populations should assume a higher number of clusters and carefully pilot recruitment strategies in preceding feasibility studies. Trial registration: ClinicalTrials.gov NCT04140929. Registered on 24 October 2019. https://clinicaltrials.gov/study/NCT04140929 .Keywords
Funding Information
- Gemeinsame Bundesausschuss (01VSF18021)
- Martin-Luther-Universität Halle-Wittenberg
This publication has 34 references indexed in Scilit:
- Change over time in characteristics and survival of residents newly admitted to nursing homes: an analysis of health insurance claims data from 2011 to 2020 in GermanyEuropean Journal of Ageing, 2025
- Entwicklung der COVID-19 Sterblichkeit in der Langzeitpflege im Verlauf der Pandemie in DeutschlandDas Gesundheitswesen, 2025
- Versorgungsforschung in Deutschland in Zeiten von COVID-19: Wie beeinflusst die Pandemie Forschungsprozesse, Methoden und die persönliche Situation von Forschenden? Eine Online-BefragungDas Gesundheitswesen, 2023
- Clinical and Subjective Oral Health Status of Care Home Residents in Europe: A Systematic ReviewJournal of the American Medical Directors Association, 2023
- „Lessons learned“ – Herausforderungen im Rekrutierungsprozess in der cluster-randomisierten Pflegeheimstudie „HIOPP-3 iTBX“Zeitschrift für Evidenz, Fortbildung und Qualität im Gesundheitswesen, 2020
- Effectiveness of a Mouth Care Program Provided by Nursing Home Staff vs Standard Care on Reducing Pneumonia IncidenceJAMA Network Open, 2020
- Improving Nursing Home Residents' Oral Hygiene: Results of a Cluster Randomized Intervention TrialJournal of the American Medical Directors Association, 2018
- Attitudes of Older Adults to Their Participation in Clinical Trials: A Pilot StudyDrugs & Aging, 2014
- Nursing home recruitment: Trials, tribulations, and successesApplied Nursing Research, 2013
- Culture, consent, costs and care homes: Enabling older people with dementia to participate in researchAging & Mental Health, 2011