A Global Positioning System for the Colon?

Authors:
  • SFS. Friedland
    S. Friedland
  • JDJ. Van Dam
    J. Van Dam

Abstract
Like the ubiquitous global positioning system (GPS), which uses orbiting satellites to determine the precise location of a receiver anywhere on Earth, the magnetic endoscope imager (MEI) is a technically advanced system capable of pinpointing the precise three-dimensional location of a colonoscope within the body. While GPS has revolutionized air, land, and sea travel, it remains to be seen whether MEI will have an equally profound impact on colonoscopic navigation. Magnetic colonoscopic imaging was developed independently by two groups of clinicians and physicists in the United Kingdom in the early 1990 s [ 1 ] [ 2 ]. The early prototypes used a specially-designed catheter passed through the accessory channel of standard endoscopes to provide real-time three-dimensional imaging of the colonoscope’s location during colonoscopy. Subsequently, the system has been refined, and it is now commercially available in the form of a colonoscope with a built-in coil-based imaging system. The advantage of the catheter-based system is that potentially any colonoscope or endoscope hanging in one’s closet may be adapted for three-dimensional imaging and localization. The advantage of the prototype magnetic imaging colonoscope is the elimination of the need to pass an imaging catheter separately during the procedure, thereby freeing the accessory channel for suctioning, lavage, and therapeutic maneuvers. The article by Wehrmann and Frühmorgen in the current issue of Endoscopy reports on initial clinical experience with prototypes of this new commercial imaging colonoscope [ 3 ]. Although the details of the magnetic imaging system design are proprietary, the physical principles of the device are conceptually straightforward. The position of the tip of the colonoscope, and multiple additional points in the shaft of the instrument, are mapped in three dimensions using sensor coils that are installed in the instrument (or the catheter) by the manufacturer [ 4 ] [ 5 ]. Sensor coils measure the rate of change of magnetic field flux according to Faraday’s law of induction: the change in magnetic field flux through the coil produces a voltage in the coil circuit that is measured. Therefore, by producing precisely controlled pulsed magnetic fields using magnetic field generators located near the patient (this is conceptually reminiscent of magnetic resonance imaging, in which much stronger precisely controlled magnetic fields are employed) it is possible to measure the location and orientation of each coil quantitatively. This information is collected several times each second, and is used to produce an image of the colonoscope on the viewing screen. Previous studies using earlier versions of the magnetic imaging system confirmed and refined several notions that clinicians performing colonoscopy have long suspected, either from experience or from using fluoroscopy during procedures [ 6 ] [ 7 ]. Loops invariably form during colonoscopy. There are loops in the sigmoid and loops in the transverse colon; without imaging, endoscopists know when looping is occurring, but can only guess at the type and location of the loops [ 8 ] [ 9 ]. With imaging, the formation and reduction of loops is clearly demonstrated. In addition, by placing a mobile sensor coil in the palm of the hand of the endoscopy assistant, it is possible to monitor the effect of abdominal pressure on looping and target the application of pressure for improved effect [ 8 ]. The three-dimensional location of the colonoscope tip is also demonstrated with imaging. Although colonoscopy reports typically chronicle the journey through various parts of the colon, the inability of endoscopists to determine the precise location of lesions has long been appreciated, and several endoscopic methods such as tattooing and clipping have been developed to address this problem [ 10 ]. In an article by Shah et al. also published in the current issue of Endoscopy [ 11 ], the application of magnetic imaging for anatomical localization of the colonoscope tip was studied prospectively. In 29 consecutive patients, the imaging system was used to determine when the colonoscope tip was located at one of four locations: the sigmoid-descending junction (eight patients), mid-transverse colon (four patients), hepatic flexure (11 patients) or splenic flexure (six patients). A random allocation determined which one of the four locations was to be the target in a given patient. Once the location was identified using the imager, two endoscopic clips were placed, contrast was injected into the bowel lumen, and a conventional radiograph was taken to allow precise identification of the clipped site. Twenty-six of the 29 nine placements were correct, using the radiography as the gold standard. The three incorrect placements had the following causes: 1) the descending colon was mistaken for the sigmoid-descending junction in one of eight patients; 2) the distal transverse colon was mistaken for the mid-transverse in one of four patients; and 3) the distal ascending colon was mistaken for the hepatic flexure in one of 11 patients. The splenic flexure was identified correctly in all six patients. All of the misidentifications were minor, in the sense that the magnetic and radiographic locations were not very distant from each other, and the authors point out that if the magnetic imager had been used as the sole method to assist a surgeon in resecting a malignancy at any of these locations, the resected area would probably have included the target lesion. However, the same authors, in an article published 2 years ago, demonstrated that the endoscopist’s unaided assessment of the scope tip position in the colon was 85 % accurate when compared to the magnetic imager [ 8 ]. We now learn that the magnetic imager is 90 % accurate when compared to the radiographic gold standard, and this naturally raises the question of...