Weibull analysis of bond strength of orthodontic buccal tubes bonded to resin composite surface with various techniques

Authors:

Abstract
The objective of this study was to analyze the survival probabilities of various surface preparation techniques for bonding buccal tubes on resin composite surface. Resin composite specimens (hybrid), 33 per group were prepared. 8 experimental groups were (1) sandblast 90 μm; (2) sandblast 50 μm; (3) abrasion using diamond bur; (4) hydrofluoric acid etching for 1 min (HF 1 min); (5) HF 2 min; (6) HF 3 min; (7) 37% orthophosphoric etching for 10 min (H 3 PO 4 10 min) and (8) control (unetched surface). Plastic conditioner was applied then buccal tubes were bonded. Shear bond strength was tested with the universal testing machine and the Weibull analysis was performed. The results at a stress level of 7.8 MPa and 10 MPa, revealed the probabilities of survival for sandblast 50 μm (100%, 99.9%), sandblast 90 μm (99.7%, 98.7%), diamond bur (98.3%, 93.4%), HF 2 min (95.9%, 85.3%), HF 1 min (78.3%, 61.4%), HF 3 min (70.6%, 46.3%), H 3 PO 4 10 min (61.4%, 44.5%) and control (26.3%, 6.9%), respectively. Therefore, surface preparation by sandblast (50 μm and 90 μm), or diamond bur followed by plastic conditioner were highly effective for bonding orthodontic buccal tubes on hybrid resin composite surface. HF 2 min was acceptable. However, HF 1 min, 3 min, H 3 PO 4 etching and unetched surface could not achieve adequate bond survival. Keywords Hybrid resin composite Weibull analysis Sandblast Diamond bur Hydrofluoric acid 1 Introduction Bonding orthodontic attachments on molar teeth has been a challenging task for orthodontists due to frequent bond failure. Inevitably, for some adult patients with periodontitis, bonding on molar teeth is preferred than banding due to several advantages, for example, less plaque accumulation, less gingival inflammation and less interproximal loss of gingival attachment during orthodontic treatment. Other advantages include decreasing difficulty for caries check-up and no residual interproximal spaces after removing bands [1,2] . In addition, buccal tubes can sometimes be bonded in places where banding is physically impossible, such as in the situation of partially erupted molars. Frequently, orthodontic bonding on artificial tooth surface was required in some adult patients, for example onlay, porcelain, metal crown, veneer, amalgam or resin composite restorations. Preparation of these surfaces with conventional method using orthophosphoric acid could not produce satisfactory bond strengths which may result in frequent disloged brackets or buccal tubes and prolonged orthodontic treatment. Therefore, researcher and clinician have experimented different techniques to increase bond strength of orthodontic attachment on these artificial surfaces by using various adhesives and surface preparation techniques [2–5] . In regard to bonding on resin composite restorations, there are only a small number of published articles on this topic. Moreover, several inconclusive approaches were reported. Generally, the methods could be mainly classified as: (1) no special surface treatment [6,7] or, (2) complex surface preparation [5,8–12] . The first group, emphasizing bonding brackets on anterior teeth, used only conventional 37% orthophosphoric acid etching on resin composite surface (microfils) for 30–60 s [6,7,11] . On the other hand, the second group used more complex techniques to prepare surface mechanically, chemically or both. Mechanical approach could be either sandblasting [8,9,12] , surface grinding with carbide bur [12] or diamond bur [13] . Chemical approach to enhance bond strength could be carried out by (1) surface etching with hydrofluoric acid [9,10] or (2) application of silane primer [5,11,12] , bonding agent [13] , or plastic conditioner [8–10] . For the situation of posterior teeth bonding, where greater bite force was concerned, the clinical recommendations was to roughen the resin composite surface mechanically with a fine diamond bur or microetcher, rinsed, and dried. The surface could then be treated with a plastic conditioner, intermediate primer or bonding enhancer, followed by an orthodontic adhesive [2,14] . At present, however, there has been no conclusive research evidence on this suggestions. How could we achieve successful and reliable bond strength when bonding buccal tube on the resin composite surface is our research question. The specific objective of our study was to analyze the survival probabilities of various surface preparation techniques for bonding buccal tubes on resin composite surface, using Weibull analysis. 2 Materials and methods 2.1 Specimen preparation Thirty-three cylindrical specimens of hybrid resin composite (Z100: 3 M ESPE, St. Paul, MN, USA) were prepared, using transparent plastic tubes measuring 5 mm internal diameter, and 7 mm height. The resin composite was condensed into the plastic tube which was placed over a glass slab. Each resin composite disc was cured using a light cure unit (3 M Curing Light XL 3000: 3 M ESPE, St. Paul, MN, USA.), from 4 different directions (top, bottom, right side and left side), for 15 s on each side. After peeling off the plastic tube, each resin composite disc was placed over the glass slab. The flat surface of each specimen was set parallel with the edge of a PVC tubular mounting ring (outer diameter 25 mm, height 40 mm) and positioned in the center of the ring. Self-curing acrylic resin was then was poured into the mounting ring. The specimens were stored in deionized water at 37 °C for 1 month before bonding (simulating 1 month aging resin composite). Eight surface preparation techniques, both mechanical and chemical methods, were performed as follows. Group (1) sandblast using aluminum oxide powder of 90 μm (sandblast 90 μm); Group (2) sandblast using aluminum oxide powder of 50 μm (sandblast 50 μm). The sandblast groups were subjected to aluminum oxide abrasive powder using a Microetcher (Danvielle Engineering, CA, USA.) at...

This publication has 16 references indexed in Scilit: