Evaluation of Criteria for Temporary External Fixation in Risk-Adapted Damage Control Orthopedic Surgery of Femur Shaft Fractures in Multiple Trauma Patients: ???Evidence-Based Medicine??? versus ???Reality??? in the Trauma Registry of the German Trauma Society
Authors:
- Dieter RixenDRDieter Rixen
- Guido GrassGGGuido Grass
- Stefan SauerlandSSStefan Sauerland
- Rolf LeferingRLRolf Lefering
- Marcus R RaumMRMarcus R Raum
- Nedim YücelNYNedim Yücel
- Bertil BouillonBBBertil Bouillon
- Edmund A M NeugebauerENEdmund A M Neugebauer
- Polytrauma Study Group of the German Trauma SocietyPSPolytrauma Study Group of the German Trauma Society
- 1 December 2005
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health
- Vol. 59 (6) , 1375-1395
Abstract
Femur-shaft fracture treatment (FSFT) follows controversial management concepts after multiple trauma: primary-definitive osteosynthesis, secondary-definitive osteosynthesis after temporary external fixation (EF) in all patients, or individualized primary- or secondary-definitive osteosynthesis ("risk-adapted damage control orthopedics"). This study compares the concepts by analyzing literature evidence and a prospective multicenter database. A systematic literature analysis was performed. The German Trauma Society trauma registry was used to assess variables predictive of treatment concept. Contradictory results in 63 controlled trials failed to support a "generalized management strategy." In all, 1,465 FSFTs in 8,057 trauma registry patients (age 39 +/- 19.5 years; Injury Severity Score [ISS] 23.5 +/- 14.9; 17.3% mortality) were treated initially (<24 hour) by EF, nail, or plate in 47.0%, 41.1%, and 11.9%, respectively. Despite large interhospital variability, EF was more likely with increasing severity of ISS, Glasgow Coma Score, thorax trauma, base excess, coagulation abnormalities, and initial probability of death. Clinical "reality" reflects the controversies of "scientific evidence" for FSFT after multiple trauma in Germany. Although decision making is currently based on unvalidated criteria, anatomic and physiologic injury severity appears to influence the choice of management concept.Keywords
This publication has 66 references indexed in Scilit:
- PULMONARY RESPONSE IN HYPOVOLEMIC SHOCK, LUNG CONTUSION AND FEMORAL FRACTURE FIXATIONShock, 1999
- Early Fracture Fixation may be Deleterious after Head InjuryThe Journal of Trauma: Injury, Infection, and Critical Care, 1997
- Posttraumatic Inflammatory Response, Secondary Operations, and Late Multiple Organ FailureThe Journal of Trauma: Injury, Infection, and Critical Care, 1996
- Organversagen bei PolytraumapatientenAINS - Anästhesiologie · Intensivmedizin · Notfallmedizin · Schmerztherapie, 1990
- Multiple injuries: Coma and fractures of the extremitiesNeurosurgical Review, 1989
- Blunt Multiple Trauma (ISS 36), Femur Traction, and the Pulmonary Failure-Septic StateAnnals of Surgery, 1985
- 57. Die primäre Oberschenkelosteosynthese beim Polytrauma: Gefahr oder Gewinn für den Patienten?Langenbeck's Archives of Surgery, 1984
- Early Osteosynthesis and Prophylactic Mechanical Ventilation in the Multitrauma Patient1982
- PRIMARY OPERATIVE FIXATION OF LONG BONE FRACTURES IN PATIENTS WITH MULTIPLE INJURIES1977
- 68. Die Mehrfachverletzung ?Besonderheiten der Indikationsstellung zur Knochenbruchbehandlung an den Extremit tenLangenbeck's Archives of Surgery, 1974