Comparison of the performance of an amplicon sequencing assay based on Oxford Nanopore technology to real-time PCR assays for detecting bacterial biodefense pathogens
Open Access
- 17 February 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Genomics
- Vol. 21 (1) , 1-21
Abstract
Background: The state-of-the-art in nucleic acid based biodetection continues to be polymerase chain reaction (PCR), and many real-time PCR assays targeting biodefense pathogens for biosurveillance are in widespread use. These assays are predominantly singleplex; i.e. one assay tests for the presence of one target, found in a single organism, one sample at a time. Due to the intrinsic limitations of such tests, there exists a critical need for high-throughput multiplex assays to reduce the time and cost incurred when screening multiple targets, in multiple pathogens, and in multiple samples. Such assays allow users to make an actionable call while maximizing the utility of the small volumes of test samples. Unfortunately, current multiplex real-time PCR assays are limited in the number of targets that can be probed simultaneously due to the availability of fluorescence channels in real-time PCR instruments. Results: To address this gap, we developed a pipeline in which the amplicons produced by a 14-plex end-point PCR assay using spiked samples were subsequently sequenced using Nanopore technology. We used bar codes to sequence multiple samples simultaneously, leading to the generation and subsequent analysis of sequence data resulting from a short sequencing run time (< 10 min). We compared the limits of detection (LoD) of real-time PCR assays to Oxford Nanopore Technologies (ONT)-based amplicon sequencing and estimated the sample-to-answer time needed for this approach. Overall, LoDs determined from the first 10 min of sequencing data were at least one to two orders of magnitude lower than real-time PCR. Given enough time, the amplicon sequencing approach is approximately 100 times more sensitive than real-time PCR, with detection of amplicon specific reads even at the lowest tested spiking concentration (around 2.5–50 Colony Forming Units (CFU)/ml). Conclusions: Based on these results, we propose amplicon sequencing assay as a viable alternative to replace the current real-time PCR based singleplex assays for higher throughput biodefense applications. We note, however, that targeted amplicon specific reads were not detectable even at the highest tested spike concentrations (2.5 X 104–5.0 X105 CFU/ml) without an initial amplification step, indicating that PCR is still necessary when utilizing this protocol.Keywords
Funding Information
- Joint Program Executive Office (NAVSEA Contract Number N00024-13-D-6400)
This publication has 17 references indexed in Scilit:
- Targeted amplification for enhanced detection of biothreat agents by next-generation sequencingBMC Research Notes, 2015
- Gene-Panel Sequencing and the Prediction of Breast-Cancer RiskNew England Journal of Medicine, 2015
- Detection of Low-Level Mixed-Population Drug Resistance in Mycobacterium tuberculosis Using High Fidelity Amplicon SequencingPLOS ONE, 2015
- Kraken: ultrafast metagenomic sequence classification using exact alignmentsGenome Biology, 2014
- FilmArray, an Automated Nested Multiplex PCR System for Multi-Pathogen Detection: Development and Application to Respiratory Tract InfectionPLOS ONE, 2011
- A statistical framework for SNP calling, mutation discovery, association mapping and population genetical parameter estimation from sequencing dataBioinformatics, 2011
- An evaluation of commercial DNA extraction kits for the isolation of bacterial spore DNA from soilJournal of Applied Microbiology, 2010
- Fast and accurate long-read alignment with Burrows–Wheeler transformBioinformatics, 2010
- Rapid differentiation and enumeration of the total, viable vegetative cell and spore content of thermophilic bacilli in milk powders with reference to Anoxybacillus flavithermusJournal of Applied Microbiology, 2005
- Genome sequencing in microfabricated high-density picolitre reactorsNature, 2005