Deconstructing the Crystal Ball: From Ad-Hoc Prediction to Principled Startup Evaluation with the SAISE Framework
Preprint
Abstract
The integration of Artificial Intelligence (AI) into startup evaluation represents a significant technological shift, yet the academic research underpinning this transition remains methodologically fragmented. Existing studies often employ ad-hoc approaches, leading to a body of work with inconsistent definitions of success, atheoretical features, and a lack of rigorous validation. This fragmentation severely limits the comparability, reliability, and practical utility of current predictive models. To address this critical gap, this paper presents a comprehensive systematic literature review of 57 empirical studies. We deconstruct the current state-of-the-art by systematically mapping the features, algorithms, data sources, and evaluation practices that define the AI-driven startup prediction landscape. Our synthesis reveals a field defined by a central paradox: a strong convergence on a common toolkit -- venture databases and tree-based ensembles -- but a stark divergence in methodological rigor. We identify four foundational weaknesses: a fragmented definition of "success," a divide between theory-informed and data-driven feature engineering, a chasm between common and best-practice model validation, and a nascent approach to data ethics and explainability. In response to these findings, our primary contribution is the proposal of the Systematic AI-driven Startup Evaluation (SAISE) Framework. This novel, five-stage prescriptive roadmap is designed to guide researchers from ad-hoc prediction toward principled evaluation. By mandating a coherent, end-to-end methodology that emphasizes stage-aware problem definition, theory-informed data synthesis, principled feature engineering, rigorous validation, and risk-aware interpretation, the SAISE framework provides a new standard for conducting more comparable, robust, and practically relevant research in this rapidly maturing domainKeywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 54 references indexed in Scilit:
- Application of Predictive Techniques for Startup Survival: The Ecuadorian CaseSN Computer Science, 2024
- Startup Success Prediction Using Machine Learning2024
- Cost‐sensitive machine learning to support startup investment decisionsIntelligent Systems in Accounting, Finance and Management, 2024
- To Invest or Not to Invest: Using Vocal Behavior to Predict Decisions of Investors in an Entrepreneurial Context2023
- Identification of Performance Contributing Features of Technology-Based Startups Using a Hybrid Framework2023
- An Experimental Study of Machine Learning Algorithms for Predicting Start-Up Success2023
- Anticipating financial distress of high‐tech startups in the European Union: A machine learning approach for imbalanced samplesJournal of Forecasting, 2022
- Identification the Determinants of Pre-revenue Young Enterprises Value2020
- The impact of entrepreneurship orientation on project performance: A machine learning approachInternational Journal of Production Economics, 2020
- Artificial intelligence and the future of work: Human-AI symbiosis in organizational decision makingBusiness Horizons, 2018