In Pursuit of Honors: A Multi-Institutional Study of Students’ Perceptions of Clerkship Evaluation and Grading
- 1 November 2019
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Academic Medicine
- Vol. 94 (11S) , S48-S56
Abstract
Purpose: To examine medical students’ perceptions of the fairness and accuracy of core clerkship assessment, the clerkship learning environment, and contributors to students’ achievement. Method: Fourth-year medical students at 6 institutions completed a survey in 2018 assessing perceptions of the fairness and accuracy of clerkship evaluation and grading, the learning environment including clerkship goal structures (mastery- or performance-oriented), racial/ethnic stereotype threat, and student performance (honors earned). Factor analysis of 5-point Likert items (1 = strongly disagree, 5 = strongly agree) provided scale scores of perceptions. Using multivariable regression, investigators examined predictors of honors earned. Qualitative content analysis of responses to an open-ended question yielded students’ recommendations to improve clerkship grading. Results: Overall response rate was 71.1% (666/937). Students believed that being liked and particular supervisors most influenced final grades. Only 44.4% agreed that grading was fair. Students felt the clerkship learning environment promoted both mastery and performance avoidance behaviors (88.0% and 85.6%, respectively). Students from backgrounds underrepresented in medicine were more likely to experience stereotype threat vulnerability (55.7% vs 10.9%, P < .0005). Honors earned was positively associated with perceived accuracy of grading and interest in competitive specialties while negatively associated with stereotype threat. Students recommended strategies to improve clerkship grading: eliminating honors, training evaluators, and rewarding improvement on clerkships. Conclusions: Participants had concerns around the fairness and accuracy of clerkship evaluation and grading and potential bias. Students expressed a need to redefine the culture of assessment on core clerkships to create more favorable learning environments for all students.Keywords
This publication has 47 references indexed in Scilit:
- Does Stereotype Threat Affect Women in Academic Medicine?Academic Medicine, 2012
- Ethnic stereotypes and the underachievement of UK medical students from ethnic minorities: qualitative studyBMJ, 2008
- An integrated process model of stereotype threat effects on performance.Psychological Review, 2008
- Is clinical competence perceived differently for student daily performance on the wards versus clerkship grading?Advances in Health Sciences Education, 2007
- Student assessmentAcademic Medicine, 1998
- A review of attribution theory in achievement contextsEducational Psychology Review, 1991
- The Impact of Classroom Evaluation Practices on StudentsReview of Educational Research, 1988
- Teachers' perceptions concerning the relative values of personal and clinical characteristics and their influence on the assignment of students' clinical gradesMedical Education, 1988
- Selection of Medical Students for Graduate Training: Pass/Fail versus GradesNew England Journal of Medicine, 1978
- Attribution Theory, Achievement Motivation, and the Educational ProcessReview of Educational Research, 1972