Revisiting Mental Simulation in Language Comprehension: Six Replication Attempts
Open Access
- 26 December 2012
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 7 (12) , e51382
Abstract
The notion of language comprehension as mental simulation has become popular in cognitive science. We revisit some of the original empirical evidence for this. Specifically, we attempted to replicate the findings from earlier studies that examined the mental simulation of object orientation, shape, and color, respectively, in sentence-picture verification. For each of these sets of findings, we conducted two web-based replication attempts using Amazon's Mechanical Turk. Our results are mixed. Participants responded faster to pictures that matched the orientation or shape implied by the sentence, replicating the original findings. The effect was larger and stronger for shape than orientation. Participants also responded faster to pictures that matched the color implied by the sentence, whereas the original studies obtained mismatch advantages. We argue that these results support mental simulation theory, show the importance of replication studies, and show the viability of web-based data collection.Keywords
This publication has 43 references indexed in Scilit:
- Looking at anything that is green when hearing “frog”: How object surface colour and stored object colour knowledge influence language-mediated overt attentionQuarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology, 2011
- Amazon's Mechanical TurkPerspectives on Psychological Science, 2011
- Rapid Communication: Readers Routinely Represent Implied Object Rotation: The Role of Visual ExperienceQuarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology, 2010
- Acquiring experiential traces in word-referent learningMemory & Cognition, 2009
- The role of color diagnosticity in object recognition and representationCognitive Processing, 2009
- Recalibrating Color Categories Using World KnowledgePsychological Science, 2008
- Hemispheric differences in the activation of perceptual information during sentence comprehensionNeuropsychologia, 2007
- The Role of Age and Perceptual Symbols in Language Comprehension.Psychology and Aging, 2004
- Perceptions of perceptual symbolsBehavioral and Brain Sciences, 1999
- What memory is forBehavioral and Brain Sciences, 1997