Sources of uncertainty in DNA metabarcoding of whole communities: Implications for its use in biomonitoring
Authors:
- J. Iwan JonesJJJ. Iwan Jones
- Amanda ArnoldAAAmanda Arnold
- Dominik BuchnerDBDominik Buchner
- John F. MurphyJMJohn F. Murphy
- Jasmine N. ChildressJCJasmine N. Childress
- Pedro BejaPBPedro Beja
- Florian AltermattFAFlorian Altermatt
- Kristian MeissnerKMKristian Meissner
- Ian AdamsIAIan Adams
- Meri AndersonMAMeri Anderson
- Yaisel J. BorrellYaisel J. Borrell
- Andrew G. BriscoeABAndrew G. Briscoe
Open Access
- 2 July 2025
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Methods in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 16 (8) , 1658-1673
Abstract
Advancements have been made in the use of DNA‐based methods for the detection of single species. However, the routine application of DNA‐based methods to monitor whole communities using a metabarcoding approach and derive ecosystem status continues to be limited. We undertook a structured experiment to assess factors influencing the precision and accuracy of molecular methods for freshwater macroinvertebrate community assessment. Macroinvertebrates were sorted, identified and counted from kick‐net samples using standard morphometric protocols, then reconstituted. These bulk specimen samples were then homogenised. From each bulk sample, aliquots of the homogenate were distributed among seven laboratories across Europe for DNA extraction, PCR amplification, library preparation and sequencing. Additionally, each laboratory was provided with a DNA extract from the bulk homogenate to allow for amplification through to sequencing, in order to assess the influence of DNA extraction. Hierarchical nested analyses were used to identify sources of uncertainty in the data and explore factors influencing the returned community and metrics of ecosystem quality. Furthermore, comparison with morphological analysis enabled us to benchmark molecular to traditional processing approaches. Metrics derived by morphological and DNA‐based methods differed substantially. The strongest methodological influences on variance in metrics derived from DNA‐based methods were attributed to sequencing (read count per sample) and laboratory (strong variation within samples). Furthermore, the performance of the DNA‐based method varied among samples, most likely due to differences in the composition of the invertebrate community. Logistic regression indicated that detectability did not vary among taxa, but that taxa occurring in low abundance (less than five individuals in our samples) were more likely to be missed via metabarcoding. Our findings highlight sources of uncertainty influencing DNA‐based methods and, particularly, the variability of results generated from individual laboratories. Our findings underline the need for clear guidelines, standardisation and quality assurance schemes.Keywords
Funding Information
- European Cooperation in Science and Technology (CA15219)
- H2020 European Research Council (852621)
This publication has 35 references indexed in Scilit:
- High frequency environmental DNA metabarcoding provides rapid and effective monitoring of fish community dynamicsEnvironmental DNA, 2023
- General principles for assignments of communities from eDNA: Open versus closed taxonomic databasesEnvironmental DNA, 2022
- Assessing changes in stream macroinvertebrate communities across ecological gradients using morphological versus DNA metabarcoding approachesScience of The Total Environment, 2021
- Metabarcoding unsorted kick‐samples facilitates macroinvertebrate‐based biomonitoring with increased taxonomic resolution, while outperforming environmental DNAEnvironmental DNA, 2020
- DNA barcode reference libraries for the monitoring of aquatic biota in Europe: Gap-analysis and recommendations for future workScience of The Total Environment, 2019
- The future of biotic indices in the ecogenomic era: Integrating (e)DNA metabarcoding in biological assessment of aquatic ecosystemsScience of The Total Environment, 2018
- Why We Need Sustainable Networks Bridging Countries, Disciplines, Cultures and Generations for Aquatic Biomonitoring 2.0: A Perspective Derived From the DNAqua-Net COST Action2018
- Sorting things out: Assessing effects of unequal specimen biomass on DNA metabarcodingEcology and Evolution, 2017
- Effect of marker choice and thermal cycling protocol on zooplankton DNA metabarcoding studiesEcology and Evolution, 2017
- Intercalibration of aquatic ecological assessment methods in the European Union: Lessons learned and way forwardEnvironmental Science & Policy, 2014