Evaluation of Different Energy Feeding Systems With Production Data from Lactating Dairy Cows Offered Grass Silage-Based Diets
Authors:
- T. YanTYT. Yan
- R.E. AgnewRAR.E. Agnew
- J.J. MurphyJMJ.J. Murphy
- C.P. FerrisCFC.P. Ferris
- F.J. GordonFGF.J. Gordon
- 1 April 2003
- journal article
- research article
- Published by American Dairy Science Association in Journal of Dairy Science
- Vol. 86 (4) , 1415-1428
Abstract
A set of data from 838 lactating dairy cows, drawn from 12 long-term feeding studies (at least 8 wk/period), was used to evaluate the energy feeding systems for dairy cows currently adopted in Australia, France, The Netherlands, the United Kingdom, and the United States. The animals were offered mixed diets of concentrates, forage [grass silages (n = 33) and corn silages (n = 5)] ad libitum. Data used in the present evaluation were either measured [dry matter (DM) intake, milk production and live weight], measured/estimated [dietary metabolizable energy (ME) concentration] or estimated [milk energy output and live weight change (LWC)]. The mean-square prediction error (MSPE) was used for the evaluation. Total ME intake, milk yields, and LWC varied from 91 to 338 MJ/d, 7.7 to 48.9, and -1.23 to 1.73 kg/d, respectively. Australian and French systems predicted total energy requirement and milk yield relatively well, while British, Dutch and American systems underpredicted total energy requirement by proportionately 0.06, 0.04, and 0.03, respectively; and overpredicted milk yield by 0.09, 0.06, and 0.04. The Agricultural and Food Research Council (AFRC) each produced a relatively larger error of the bias (predicted - actual data) over the total MSPE for ME requirement and milk yield and a relatively smaller error of random than other systems. However, an addition of proportionately 0.05 to the total predicted ME requirement of AFRC, as suggested in this system and currently used in the UK, indicated the prediction accuracy of ME requirement and milk yield is similar to Australian and French systems. Nevertheless, all the systems had a poor prediction of LWC. For each system, the total prediction error (total MSPE) was mainly derived from the line (slope; 0.49 to 0.64 of total MSPE), while less derived from the random (0.20 to 0.48 of total MSPE), indicating a large variation between the predicted and actual LWC existed among individual cows. The residual plots of the residual differences in LWC against predicted LWC revealed that the prediction error was greater with increasing LWC. It is concluded that Australian and French systems have a better prediction of total energy requirement and milk yield than other systems, and LWC is an inappropriate indicator of energy balance in lactating dairy cows.Keywords
This publication has 29 references indexed in Scilit:
- Impact of recent research on energy feeding systems for dairy cattleLivestock Production Science, 2000
- An examination of energy utilization in lactating dairy cows receiving a total mixed ration based on maize silageAnimal Science, 2000
- The effect of genetic merit and concentrate proportion in the diet on nutrient utilization by lactating dairy cowsThe Journal of Agricultural Science, 1999
- The influence of dairy cow genetic merit on the direct and residual response to level of concentrate supplementationThe Journal of Agricultural Science, 1999
- The effects of energy source and level of digestible undegradable protein in concentrates on silage intake and performance of lactating dairy cows offered a range of grass silagesAnimal Science, 1999
- A comparison of low starch maize silage and grass silage and the effect of concentrate supplementation of the forages or inclusion of maize grain with the maize silage on milk production by dairy cowsLivestock Production Science, 1999
- The effects of concentrate energy source on silage feeding behaviour and energy utilization by lactating dairy cows offered grass silages with differing intake characteristicsAnimal Science, 1998
- The effects of treating low dry matter herbage with a bacterial inoculant or formic acid on the intake and performance of lactating dairy cattleAnimal Science, 1997
- Effects of inoculant treatment on ryegrass silage fermentation, digestibility, rumen fementation, intake and performance of lactating dairy cattleGrass and Forage Science, 1996
- The digestibility and metabolisable energy content of grass silage and their prediction from laboratory measurementsAnimal Feed Science and Technology, 1989