Predictive Versus Measured Energy Expenditure Using Limits‐of‐Agreement Analysis in Hospitalized, Obese Patients
Authors:
- Geoffrey W. GreeneGGGeoffrey W. Greene
- Marion F. WinklerMWMarion F. Winkler
- Jorge E. AlbinaJAJorge E. Albina
- 1 May 1999
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Parenteral and Enteral Nutrition
- Vol. 23 (3) , 147-154
Abstract
Background: Accuracy of predictive formulae is crucial for therapeutic planning because indirect calorimetry measurement is not always possible or cost effective. Energy requirements are more difficult to predict in the acutely ill obese patient compared with lean patients because of an increased resting energy expenditure per lean body mass and a variable stress response to illness. Methods: A retrospective review of 726 patients identified 57 patients (32 spontaneous breathing, S; 25 ventilator dependent, V) with body mass indexes of 30–50 kg/m2. Limits‐of‐agreement analysis determined bias (the mean difference between measured and predicted values) and precision (the standard deviation of the bias) to evaluate the accuracy of predictive formulae compared with measured resting energy expenditure (MREE) by a Deltatrac Metabolic Monitor. Predictive accuracy was determined within ±10% MREE. The predictive formulae examined were: variations of the Harris‐Benedict equations using ideal, adjusted weights of 25% and 50% and actual weights with stress factors ranging from 1.0 to 1.5; the Ireton‐Jones equation for obesity; the Ireton—Jones equations for hospitalized patients (S and V); and the ratio of 21 kcalories per kilogram actual weight. Results: The mean MREE was 21 kcal/kg actual weight. The adjusted Harris‐Benedict average weight equation was optimal for predicting MREE for the combined S and V sets (bias = 182 ± 123; 67% ± 10% MREE), as well as the S subset (bias = 159 ± 112; 69% ± 10% MREE). Conclusions: The Harris‐Benedict equations using the average of actual and ideal weight and a stress factor of 1.3 most accurately predicted MREE in acutely ill, obese patients with BMIs of 30–50 kg/m2. Predictive formulae were least accurate for obese, ventilator‐dependent patients. (Journal of Parenteral and Enteral Nutrition 23:147–154, 1999)Keywords
This publication has 33 references indexed in Scilit:
- Nutrition Support of Obese Hospitalized PatientsNutrition in Clinical Practice, 1997
- Human Body Composition: Advances in Models and MethodsAnnual Review of Nutrition, 1997
- Formulaic Methods of Estimating Calorie Requirements in Mechanically Ventilated Obese Patients: A ReappraisalNutrition in Clinical Practice, 1995
- Obesity: Nutrition Support Practice and Application to Critical CareNutrition in Clinical Practice, 1995
- Invited Review: Use of Indirect Calorimetry in Clinical NutritionNutrition in Clinical Practice, 1992
- Measurement of gas exchange in intensive careCritical Care Medicine, 1989
- Invited Review: Nutrition Support of the Stressed Obese PatientNutrition in Clinical Practice, 1989
- Resting Energy Expenditure in Moderate ObesityAnnals of Surgery, 1986
- STATISTICAL METHODS FOR ASSESSING AGREEMENT BETWEEN TWO METHODS OF CLINICAL MEASUREMENTThe Lancet, 1986
- Measured and predicted resting energy expenditure in clinically stable patients*Clinical Nutrition, 1984