Many ground-nesting shorebirds lay clutches with cryptically colored eggs that contribute to clutch camouflage through background matching or disruptive patterns. In contrast, the occurrence of conspicuously colored eggs is highly unusual in this clade, presumably because such eggs would increase clutch detectability by predators. Among ruffs (Calidris pugnax) breeding on coastal Baltic meadows in Finland, we detected an unusually high number of clutches that contained aberrantly colored (often blue or rarely white) eggs. First, we examined within- and between-year frequencies of ‘blue-egg clutches’ in both historical (1984–1987, 1990) and contemporary data (2018–2026). Second, we tested whether the incidence of ’blue-egg clutches’ has changed over time within the extensive contemporary data set (609 nests). Finally, we ran an experiment testing whether the camouflage of these clutches was compromised relative to the typically colored clutches and compared daily nest survival between clutch types. Aberrantly colored eggs were recorded in 6.00 % of the historical and in 9.35 % of the clutches in contemporary data, where we also detected a linear increase in occurrence of such clutches over the course of nine years. ‘Blue-egg clutches’ were neither detected more quickly by fieldworkers, nor subject to higher predation mortality compared to the typically colored clutches. Rather, search time, our proxy for clutch detectability, was best predicted by whether a female was seen flushing from the nest upon approach by a human observer. This suggests that fitness consequences of blue eggshell coloration are limited for our population. However, we highlight the need for continued monitoring across additional populations and species, as fitness consequences may be species specific and habitat dependent.