Eddies in the third wave: Protracted transitions and theories of democratization
Author:
- 1 September 2000
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Democratization
- Vol. 7 (3) , 3-24
Abstract
In the third wave's backwaters, where transitions are protracted and authoritarians seem unsinkable, incremental bargaining is the path for persistent opposition parties. This article outlines tentative propositions about actors and arenas of protracted transition, in reference to the under‐specified cases of transitions to democracy considered in this volume. It offers a general characterization of protracted transitions, drawing upon scant existing literature, but adding a more developed opposition‐based perspective to conventional depictions of authoritarian behaviour. Next, it specifies possible incentives for actors within opposition parties, and discusses the parties’ overall preferences in the trade‐off between short‐term co‐optation by the regime and longer‐term efforts to undermine the authoritarians. Finally it considers why the understudied electoral arena is so critical to these transitions, and offers four main reasons why opposition parties are such crucial actors. First, they have little to lose, at least in terms of their group's power within the regime. Second, effective opposition parties must remain ‘cause pure’ (at least for the most part) even given their need to broaden their coalition to reach a broader electorate, and despite temptations to submit to incumbent attempts at co‐optation. Third, the opposition parties must accept that unless external or economic factors intervene to turn a protracted transition into an abrupt one, the time horizon of the transition will be extended, and sheer endurance will be a great part of the challenge to the regime opposition. Fourth, even as opposition parties in some regions, or even at the national level, extract concessions, such concessions do not extend uniformly.Keywords
This publication has 14 references indexed in Scilit:
- Democratic Experiments in Africa1997
- Myths of Moderation: Confrontation and Conflict during Democratic TransitionsComparative Politics, 1997
- The Political Economy of Democratic Transitions1996
- The Polish games of transitionCommunist and Post-Communist Studies, 1994
- Institutions and Social Conflict1992
- A Behavioral Theory of Competitive Political PartiesAmerican Journal of Political Science, 1990
- Rethinking Military Politics1988
- Transitions to Democracy and Transition through TransactionComparative Political Studies, 1987
- Opening through Elections: Will the Brazilian Case Become a Paradigm?Government and Opposition, 1984
- Elections Without Choice1978