Using Expectancy Value Theory to Account for Individuals’ Mathematical Justifications
- 4 August 2019
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Cognition and Instruction
- Vol. 38 (1) , 27-56
Abstract
In mathematics education, researchers commonly infer students’ standards of conviction from the justifications that they produce. Specifically, if students justify a mathematical statement with an empirical justification, researchers often infer that example-based justifications provide the students with certainty that a general mathematical statement is true. In this article, we present a theoretical framework for interpreting individuals’ proof-related behavior that challenges the aforementioned interpretations. Adapting constructs from expectancy value theory, we argue that whether an individual will seek a deductive proof or settle for an empirical justification depends on several factors, including the value they place on knowing the veracity of the mathematical statement being considered, the cost in terms of time and effort in searching for a proof, and their perceived likelihood of success of being able to find a proof. We demonstrate that mathematicians consider value, cost, and effort in deciding what statements they will try to prove, so it would not be irrational or unmathematical for students to make the same considerations. We illustrate the explanatory power of our framework by studying the justification behavior of 11 preservice and in-service secondary mathematics teachers in a problem-solving course. Although these individuals frequently justified mathematical statements empirically, these individuals were aware of the limitations of empirical justifications and they usually did not obtain certainty from these justifications. The notions of value, cost, and likelihood of success could explain why they settled for empirical justifications and ceased seeking proofs.Keywords
This publication has 44 references indexed in Scilit:
- Why and how mathematicians read proofs: an exploratory studyEducational Studies in Mathematics, 2011
- Proof constructions and evaluationsEducational Studies in Mathematics, 2009
- Modelling mathematical argumentation: the importance of qualificationEducational Studies in Mathematics, 2007
- Using thematic analysis in psychologyQualitative Research in Psychology, 2006
- Validations of Proofs Considered as Texts: Can Undergraduates Tell Whether an Argument Proves a Theorem?Journal for Research in Mathematics Education, 2003
- On Two Metaphors for Learning and the Dangers of Choosing Just OneEducational Researcher, 1998
- Unpacking the logic of mathematical statementsEducational Studies in Mathematics, 1995
- Proving is convincing and explainingEducational Studies in Mathematics, 1993
- High school geometry students' justification for their views of empirical evidence and mathematical proofEducational Studies in Mathematics, 1993
- When the Problem Is Not the Question and the Solution Is Not the Answer: Mathematical Knowing and TeachingAmerican Educational Research Journal, 1990