LANGUAGE TRANSFER AND DISCOURSE UNIVERSALS IN INDIAN ENGLISH ARTICLE USE
- 25 October 2005
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Studies in Second Language Acquisition
- Vol. 27 (04) , 535-566
Abstract
Stable nonnative varieties of English acquired and used in the absence of native English input can diverge systematically from native varieties over time (Cheshire, 1991; Kachru, 1983; Platt, Weber, & Ho, 1984). Focusing on Indian English article use, this study asks the following question: If divergence is indeed occurring, do new features derive primarily from first language (L1) transfer or from universal principles? Natural conversational speech is assessed in relation to four hypotheses relating to L1 transfer and language universals, and a multivariate regression analysis evaluates the relative strength of each factor. The new article system is not found to be identical to the L1 article system. Although L1 transfer appears to be operative when an overt form (the specific indefinite article) exists in the L1, when a gap occurs in the L1 (no definite article), speakers do not completely omit the definite article in their second language English. Using Prince's (1981) taxonomy of assumed familiarity, it is shown that the absence of a L1 model for definite articles permits the intervention of universally available discourse knowledge, such that speakers apply an economical, disambiguating principle to the use of overt articles, reserving them mainly for new (less given or inferable) information and omitting them in more redundant contexts.I am indebted to John Rickford, Elizabeth Traugott, Arnold Zwicky, Ishtla Singh, and the SSLA editors and anonymous reviewers for much helpful feedback. I also received valuable comments from audiences at the LSA, Atlanta (January 2003) and at UC Davis and UC San Diego (February 2003).Keywords
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- Dialect stabilization and speaker awareness in non‐native varieties of English1Journal of Sociolinguistics, 2005
- On Definite Reference in World EnglishesWorld Englishes, 2003
- SECOND LANGUAGE LEARNERS' THEORIES ON THE USE OF ENGLISH ARTICLESStudies in Second Language Acquisition, 2002
- TOPIC CONTINUITY IN L2 ENGLISH ARTICLE USEStudies in Second Language Acquisition, 2002
- Torn between the norms: innovations in world EnglishesWorld Englishes, 1998
- Non-Native Varieties of English1987
- Sociolinguistic theory and non-native varieties of EnglishLingua, 1986
- Referential and quantificational indefinitesLinguistics and Philosophy, 1982
- Errors and Strategies in Child Second Language AcquisitionTESOL Quarterly, 1974
- TheIndiannessin Indian EnglishWORD, 1965