Scarcity
Authors:
- Andrew B. CooperACAndrew B. Cooper
- Robert SibbaldRSRobert Sibbald
- Damon C. ScalesDSDamon C. Scales
- Linda RozmovitsLRLinda Rozmovits
- Tasnim SinuffTSTasnim Sinuff
- 1 June 2013
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Critical Care Medicine
- Vol. 41 (6) , 1476-1482
Abstract
Objectives: Clinicians’ perceptions of scarcity influence rationing of critical care resources, which may lead to serious adverse outcomes for patients who are denied access. We sought to better understand the phenomenon of scarcity in the critical care setting. Design: Qualitative research methods. We used purposeful sampling to recruit ICU clinicians who were frequently involved in decisions to allocate ICU resources. Thematic analysis was performed to identify concepts related to the phenomenon of scarcity. Setting: An ICU of a university-affiliated hospital in Toronto, Canada, between October and December 2007. Subjects: We conducted 22 interviews with 12 ICU physicians, 4 ICU fellows, 2 ICU nursing team leaders, and 4 ICU resource nurses. Main Results: The perception of scarcity arose from a complex interaction of factors within the institution including: 1) practices of non-ICU physicians (e.g., failure to specify end-of-life treatment plans or to secure an ICU bed prior to elective high-risk surgery), 2) family demands for life support and clinicians’ perception of a lack of legal support if they opposed these, and 3) inability to transfer patients to non-ICU care settings in a timely manner. Implications of scarcity included: 1) diversions of critically ill patients, 2) premature patient transfers, 3) temporary delivery of critical care in non-ICU locations (e.g., emergency department, postanesthesia care unit), and 4) interprofessional conflicts. Conclusions: ICU clinicians’ perceptions of scarcity may lead to rationing of critical care resources. We found that nonmedical factors strongly influenced prioritization activity, both for admission and discharge. Although scarcity of ICU beds might be mitigated by process improvements such as patient flow or proactive communication, our findings highlight the importance of a fair process for inevitable limit setting at the bedside.Keywords
This publication has 14 references indexed in Scilit:
- Refusal of Intensive Care Unit Admission Due to a Full Unit: Impact on MortalityAmerican Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine, 2012
- Long-Term Ambient Multipollutant Exposures and MortalityAmerican Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine, 2011
- Reasons for refusal of admission to intensive care and impact on mortalityIntensive Care Medicine, 2010
- Priority-setting in healthcare: a framework for reasonable clinical judgementsJournal of Medical Ethics, 2009
- Priority setting and cardiac surgery: A qualitative case studyHealth Policy, 2007
- Communication of bed allocation decisions in a critical care unit and accountability for reasonablenessBMC Health Services Research, 2005
- Rationing critical care beds: A systematic review*Critical Care Medicine, 2004
- Priority setting in a hospital critical care unit: Qualitative case study*Critical Care Medicine, 2003
- Access to intensive care unit beds for neurosurgery patients: a qualitative case studyJournal of Neurology, Neurosurgery & Psychiatry, 2003
- Influence of political power, medical provincialism, and economic incentives on the rationing of surgical intensive care unit bedsCritical Care Medicine, 1992