Comparing Direct and Indirect Measures of Just Rewards
Authors:
- 1 February 2012
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Sociological Methods & Research
- Vol. 41 (1) , 199-216
Abstract
We offer the first comparison between “direct” and “indirect” methods for measuring perceptions of distributive justice in reward allocations. The direct method simply asks respondents what they would consider to be a fair salary for a particular person in a given set of circumstances. In contrast, the indirect method infers fair salaries from respondents’ judgments about the relative unfairness of hypothetical salaries. The particular indirect method that we will assess is a vignette survey technique pioneered by Jasso and Rossi (1977) and used in a number of more recent publications. The vignettes describe characteristics of a hypothetical employee, with the objective of deriving what respondents believe to be the just reward for that employee. Our experimental test suggests that the two methods yield incompatible results and that neither is immune to bias. The indirect method also suffers from a type of specification error that leads to untenable results. We conclude by suggesting directions for new research to gain a better understanding of these problems and, ultimately, to circumvent them.Keywords
This publication has 21 references indexed in Scilit:
- Distributive Justice and CEO CompensationActa Sociologica, 2008
- Factorial Survey Methods for Studying Beliefs and JudgmentsSociological Methods & Research, 2006
- Justice Processes: Specifying the Mediating Role of Perceptions of Distributive JusticeAmerican Sociological Review, 2001
- Assessing the Gender Gap in Just Earnings and Its Underlying MechanismsSocial Psychology Quarterly, 1999
- Double Standards in Just Earnings for Male and Female WorkersSocial Psychology Quarterly, 1997
- Heuristics and biases in equity judgments: A utilitarian approach1993
- Methods for the Theoretical and Empirical Analysis of Comparison ProcessesSociological Methodology, 1990
- Toward a Multilevel Distributive Justice TheoryAmerican Sociological Review, 1985
- On the Justice of Earnings: A New Specification of the Justice Evaluation FunctionAmerican Journal of Sociology, 1978
- Distributive Justice and Earned IncomeAmerican Sociological Review, 1977