Bariatric Outcomes Longitudinal Database (BOLD) Suggests Excess Weight Loss and Excess BMI Loss To Be Inappropriate Outcome Measures, Demonstrating Better Alternatives
- 25 August 2012
- journal article
- Published by Springer Nature in Obesity Surgery
- Vol. 22 (12) , 1843-1847
Abstract
Excess weight loss (%EWL) results show significant variation by initial body mass index (BMI): the heavier the patient, the lower the result. It is unclear whether this effect originates from the arithmetic construction of this outcome measure or from any true difference in bariatric impact on heavier and lighter patients. Outcome measures generating inappropriate variation would actually be unsuited for bariatric reports with possible implications on existing bariatric evidence. Nadir weight loss results after laparoscopic gastric bypass in 7,212 women from the Bariatric Outcomes Longitudinal Database (BOLD) are calculated for %EWL and 26 different relative measures using the formula 100 % × (initial BMI − nadir BMI)/(initial BMI − a), with reference point 0 ≤ a ≤ 25. Variations by initial BMI and deviations in results using each relative measure are compared. Mean initial BMI, 47.5 kg/m2. Mean nadir BMI, 28.9 kg/m2. Mean nadir results of the lighter (A) and heavier (B) halves (2× n=3, 606) by reference point, a=25 (excess BMI loss (%EBMIL)), 95.3 % (A)–77.2 % (B); a=ideal weight (%EWL), 81.7 % (A)–70.4 % (B); a=10, 49.6 % (A)–49.7 % (B); a=0 (total weight loss (%TWL)), 37.7 % (A)–40.2 % (B). Variation by initial BMI is significant using all relative measures, except those with a = 9 (p = 0.396) and a = 10 (p = 0.504). The smallest variation coefficient is 21.5 % at 8 ≤ a ≤ 14. Gastric bypass works equally effective for all female patients, reducing the part of body mass above 10 kg/m2 by an average of 49.6 %, regardless of their initial BMI. In contrast, %EWL and %EBMIL generate variation by initial BMI, providing lighter patients inappropriately with better results, potentially interfering with the significance of bariatric evidence. These two most widespread used outcome measures in bariatric surgery are therefore actually unsuited for comparing patients or groups. This BOLD data makes a strong argument for abandoning %EWL and %EBMIL altogether and reporting bariatric relative outcome as %TWL only.Keywords
This publication has 11 references indexed in Scilit:
- Preoperative Predictors of Weight Loss Following Bariatric Surgery: Systematic ReviewObesity Surgery, 2011
- Mortality of eating disorders: A follow‐up study of treatment in a specialist unit 1974–2000International Journal of Eating Disorders, 2011
- Relative Outcome Measures for Bariatric Surgery. Evidence Against Excess Weight Loss and Excess Body Mass Index Loss from a Series of Laparoscopic Roux-en-Y Gastric Bypass PatientsObesity Surgery, 2011
- Minimal Reporting Requirements for Weight Loss: Current Methods Not IdealObesity Surgery, 2005
- Twenty Years of Biliopancreatic Diversion: What is the Goal of the Surgery?Obesity Surgery, 2004
- Laparoscopic Gastric Bypass Versus Laparoscopic Adjustable Gastric BandingJournal of the American College of Surgeons, 2003
- Laparoscopic Roux-en-Y Gastric Bypass for Morbid ObesityArchives of Surgery, 2000
- Standards for Reporting ResultsObesity Surgery, 1994
- 1983 metropolitan height and weight tables.1983
- CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF LONG-TERM WEIGHT-LOSS FOLLOWING GASTRIC BYPASS1982