Beyond One Size Fits All: A Cultural Informed Comparative Study of ICT Integration in Malaysian Elementary Schools
Preprint
- 29 October 2025
- preprint
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Square
Abstract
One National Type Chinese School and one National School are chosen as case studies to investigate the cultural influence of ICT integration in two high performing urban Malaysian elementary schools. Research aims to examine key contradictions and their resolutions in integrating ICT into teaching among teachers and to explore how governance structures are designed to support ICT integration success. A qualitative multiple case study design was adopted, primary data collection was semi structured interviews, and triangulated with non participant observations and document analysis involving 14 teachers. The analysis was guided by the Cultural Historical Activity Theory (CHAT) framework on the ICT integration implementation process in teaching and learning. Three common contradictions emerged across both schools: inadequate school ICT facilities due to financial limitations, non compliance due to workload and time constraints, and non compliance rooted in resistance to change. Despite these shared challenges, the schools adopted different strategies to manage tensions, particularly in how assisted performance was governed. The National Type Chinese School emphasised collaborative peer mentoring, while the National School relied on top down instructional guidance. Both were also influenced by their respective cultural and institutional contexts, demonstrated shared strategies of idea sharing and distributed leadership. This study reveals how cultural and structural differences shape both the problems and the solutions in digital pedagogical practices, and challenges the universality of ICT integration frameworks. It highlights the need for cultural responsive policies and teacher development models.Keywords
All Related Versions
Funding Information
- Universiti Pendidikan Sultan Idris (Article Processing within Transformative Agreement)
This publication has 45 references indexed in Scilit:
- Contradictions in Teachers’ Classroom Dynamic Assessment Implementation: An Activity System AnalysisTESOL Quarterly, 2021
- The role of TPACK in affecting pre-service language teachers’ ICT integration during teaching practices: Indonesian contextEducation and Information Technologies, 2019
- Moderating effect of innovation consciousness and quality consciousness on intention-behaviour relationship in E-learning integrationEducation and Information Technologies, 2019
- Augmented reflective learning and knowledge retention perceived among students in classrooms involving virtual laboratoriesEducation and Information Technologies, 2017
- An Activity Theoretical Approach Towards Distributed Leadership for One-to-One Computing in a Singapore Elementary School2016
- ICT, education and older people in Australia: A socio-technical analysisEducation and Information Technologies, 2013
- Challenges facing school leadership in promoting ICT integration in instruction in the public schools of BahrainEducation and Information Technologies, 2013
- Evolutionary Psychology in the Business Sciences2011
- Activity Systems Analysis Methods2010
- Activity theory as a framework for designing constructivist learning environmentsEducational Technology Research and Development, 1999