Below the Belt: Doctors, Debate, and the Ongoing American Discussion of Routine Neonatal Male Circumcision
Author:
- 1 August 2001
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Bulletin of Science, Technology & Society
- Vol. 21 (4) , 297-311
Abstract
There has been considerable controversy surrounding the routine circumcision of male infants in the United States. This is of particular concern, since the medical establishments of all the other countries of the developed world have abandoned this procedure as having dubious benefits. This article examines the medical pros and cons of neonatal male circumcision in a historical perspective and suggests that the circumstances that led to its establishment as a routine practice are largely absent today. Reasons for its continued use and ethical and moral issues associated with its practice are then examined closely, especially in light of the current debate surrounding female circumcision. The article concludes that the medical and ethical issues surrounding this practice should be more broadly debated until there is some consensus as to its benefits. Prudence dictates that until such a consensus emerges, the practice should be suspended.Keywords
This publication has 14 references indexed in Scilit:
- New Policy on Circumcision—Cause for ConcernPediatrics, 2000
- Circumcision Policy StatementPediatrics, 1999
- Neonatal Circumcision and Pain Relief: Current Training PracticesPediatrics, 1998
- Circumcision in the United StatesJAMA, 1997
- The prepuce: specialized mucosa of the penis and its loss to circumcisionBritish Journal of Urology, 1996
- The Status of Circumcision of NewbornsNew England Journal of Medicine, 1990
- Socially camouflaged technologies: the case of the electromechanical vibratorIEEE Technology and Society Magazine, 1989
- THE PREPUCE: A MISTAKE OF NATURE?The Lancet, 1989
- Whither the Foreskin?JAMA, 1970
- Ritualistic Surgery — Circumcision and TonsillectomyNew England Journal of Medicine, 1969