Characterization of reading errors in languages with different orthographic regularity: an Italian-English comparison

Authors:

Abstract
The study examined whether a classification of errors based on Hendriks and Kolk’s (1997) proposal would effectively characterize the reading profile of children learning two orthographies varying for regularity, such as Italian and English. The study considered both an age-match and a school-match comparisons. Offline analysis of error production was carried out for two lists of stimuli: List 1 including regular words varying for frequency and matched non-words) and List 2 including low-frequency words varying for regularity. In List 1, Italian made mostly multiple attempts characterized by a slow and progressive approach to the target (sounding-out behavior) while English children showed a prevalence of word substitutions and non-word lexicalizations. As for List 2, Italian children again made more multiple attempts and progressive approach to the target (with more sounding-out behaviors and syllabications), while the English children made more phonological-visual errors, word substitutions, morphological, and semantic errors. Both groups showed a high proportion of phonological-visual and regularization errors (stress assignment in the case of Italian children). Overall, the use of an error coding system specifically tuned to the characteristics of the orthographies investigated allowed a more comprehensive identification of reading difficulties which made emerge more clearly the different strategies used by children of different language in reaching orthographic proficiency (more reliance on the sub-lexical routine in Italian and on lexical routines in English). These results call for more attention to error patterns in the identification of reading difficulties in children of different languages including those learning a transparent orthography where error analyses have largely been ignored.