Reconceptualizing Dialogue in Environmental Public Participation
Authors:
- 1 November 2006
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Policy Studies Journal
- Vol. 34 (4) , 755-775
Abstract
In this article we argue that the attempt to overcome technical dominance with democratic procedures has reduced communication to fair procedural rules that do not fully recognize the rhetorical functions of dialogue. The meaning generation process, although important, is not sufficiently accounted for in current participation theories and models. Here, we use Mikhail Bakhtin's dialogic perspective to explore a “sense‐making” discourse that includes embracing differences, generating new meanings, and engaging in an open‐ended dialogue. This mode of discourse works to construct understanding through a multi‐voiced, ongoing struggle among perspectives. It intermingles with a problem‐solving discourse focused on developing agreement among disparate views within democratic processes. These types of discourse have differing, yet complimentary goals and we see them as alternating throughout public participation to encourage long‐term interaction and relationship building. We highlight techniques that illustrate some ways of encouraging a sense‐making discourse and touch upon several lessons they provide for implementing this type of discourse within democratic models.Keywords
This publication has 36 references indexed in Scilit:
- An Evaluation of DOE-EM Public Participation Programs2003
- The Quality of Stakeholder‐Based DecisionsRisk Analysis, 2002
- Evaluating the application of collaborative learning to the Wenatchee fire recovery planning effortEnvironmental Impact Assessment Review, 2001
- Deliberative Democracy in Practice: Challenges and Prospects for Civic DeliberationPolity, 1999
- The Limits of Consensus: The Environmental Protection System in Transition: Toward a More Desirable FutureEnvironment: Science and Policy for Sustainable Development, 1999
- An Evaluation of the Effectiveness of Local Site-Specific Advisory Boards for US Department of Energy Environmental Restoration Programs1999
- Toward a Normative Conception of Difference in Public DeliberationArgumentation and Advocacy, 1999
- Deliberative Democracy1997
- Futuresite: An Environmental Remediation Game-SimulationSimulation & Gaming, 1997
- Reasonable Democracy1996