An ecosystem-based management strategy evaluation of harvest control rules for Norwegian spring-spawning herring (Clupea harengus L.)
Open Access
- 2 September 2025
- journal article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in ICES Journal of Marine Science
- Vol. 82 (9)
Abstract
Norwegian spring-spawning herring (Clupea harengus L.) play a vital ecological and socio-economic role in the Northeast Atlantic and Arctic Oceans, with several coastal states and fishing nations participating in the fishery. The stock collapsed in the 1960s due to environmental changes and overfishing, prompting changes in management. A harvest control rule was introduced in a long-term management plan agreed upon by the coastal states in 1999, aiding stock recovery. In 2018, the International Council for the Exploration of the Sea (ICES) conducted a benchmark and management strategy evaluation, leading to a revised long-term management plan implemented in 2019. Although Norwegian spring-spawning herring, as forage fish, are prime candidates for ecosystem-based fisheries management, the current ICES management strategy evaluation omitted ecosystem interactions. Our study employed an ecosystem-based operating model (Atlantis) to test and evaluate four threshold harvest control rules for Norwegian spring-spawning herring, considering uncertainty in recruitment and zooplankton biomass. The candidate harvest control rules included the previous long-term management plan (1999–2018), the current long-term management plan (2019–present), and two harvest control rules that varied the target fishing mortality and spawning stock biomass reference thresholds. In our results, the previous long-term management plan often led to greater long-term Norwegian spring-spawning herring biomass and catch with less catch variation, outperforming the current long-term management strategy. We discuss our findings in the context of balancing the parameterizations of harvest control rule reference points to support long-term catch and stock biomass under an ecosystem context. Incorporating ecosystem models into management strategy evaluation, alongside the more commonly used single-species models, offers a more comprehensive and nuanced understanding of the impacts of alternative fishery strategies when evaluating Norwegian spring-spawning herring harvest control rules. This aligns with ICES objectives for sustainable seafood provision and marine ecosystem understanding.Keywords
Funding Information
- European Commission (#303663)
- Research Council of Norway Marinforsk Programme
This publication has 59 references indexed in Scilit:
- Ecosystem-level reference points: Moving toward ecosystem-based fisheries managementMarine and Coastal Fisheries, 2024
- Atlantis Ecosystem Model Summit 2022: Report from a workshopEcological Modelling, 2023
- New approaches to old problems: how to introduce ecosystem information into modern fisheries management adviceHydrobiologia, 2022
- Making spatial-temporal marine ecosystem modelling better – A perspectiveEnvironmental Modelling & Software, 2021
- Direct and ancillary benefits of ecosystem‐based fisheries management in forage fish fisheriesEcological Applications, 2021
- Interspecific Interactions May Influence Reef Fish Management Strategies in the Gulf of MexicoMarine and Coastal Fisheries, 2018
- Evaluation of threshold management strategies for groundfish off the U.S. West CoastFisheries Research, 2008
- A review of harvest policies: Understanding relative performance of control rulesFisheries Research, 2008
- Meta-ecosystems and biological energy transport from ocean to coast: the ecological importance of herring migrationOecologia, 2005
- Biogeochemical marine ecosystem models I: IGBEM—a model of marine bay ecosystemsEcological Modelling, 2004