The medium is the message: toxicity declines in structured vs unstructured online deliberations
Open Access
- 8 May 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in World Wide Web
- Vol. 27 (3) , 1-30
Abstract
Humanity needs to deliberate effectively at scale about highly complex and contentious problems. Current online deliberation tools—such as email, chatrooms, and forums—are however plagued by levels of discussion toxicity that deeply undercut the willingness and ability of the participants to engage in thoughtful, meaningful, deliberations. This has led many organizations to either shut down their forums or invest in expensive, frequently unreliable, and ethically fraught moderation of people's contributions in their forums. This paper includes a comprehensive review on online toxicity, and describes how a structured deliberation process can substantially reduce toxicity compared to current approaches. The key underlying insight is that unstructured conversations create, especially at scale, an “attention wars” dynamic wherein people are often incented to resort to extremified language in order to get visibility for their postings. A structured deliberation process wherein people collaboratively create a compact organized collection of answers and arguments removes this underlying incentive, and results, in our evaluation, in a 50% reduction of high-toxicity posts.Keywords
Funding Information
- Massachusetts Institute of Technology
This publication has 102 references indexed in Scilit:
- Incivility in online learning environment: Perception of dental students and facultyJournal of Dental Education, 2022
- Misleading political advertising fuels incivility online: A social network analysis of 2020 U.S. presidential election campaign video comments on YouTubeComputers in Human Behavior, 2022
- Does negative campaign advertising stimulate uncivil communication on social media? Measuring audience response using big dataComputers in Human Behavior, 2017
- Online Incivility and Public Debate2017
- A Systematic Review of Online Deliberation ResearchPolicy & Internet, 2015
- Crowdsourcing civility: A natural experiment examining the effects of distributed moderation in online forumsGovernment Information Quarterly, 2014
- Social media as a catalyst for online deliberation? Exploring the affordances of Facebook and YouTube for political expressionComputers in Human Behavior, 2013
- Hypermedia Support for Argumentation-Based Rationale2007
- Using Computer Supported Argument Visualization to Teach Legal Argumentation2003
- The cathedral and the bazaarKnowledge and Policy, 1999