Influence of Pore Pressure on Drilling Response in Hard Shales
Authors:
- 1 December 1994
- journal article
- Published by Society of Petroleum Engineers (SPE) in SPE Drilling & Completion
- Vol. 9 (04) , 263-270
Abstract
Summary Results are presented from laboratory drilling studies of two different hard shales similar to those found in some areas of the North Sea. Two laboratory drilling machines with milled-tooth bits were used. Pore pressure was measured in all the experiments, and in some it was reduced to several megapascals below bottomhole pressure (BHP). Pore-pressure reduction was achieved by allowing the pore fluid to drain out of the shale while external stresses were maintained constant. The influence of BHP was studied for values from 3 to 33 Mpa [435 to 4,786 psi]. The differential pressure, which equals BHP minus pore pressure, ranged from near balance to >10 Mpa [>1,450 psi]. BHP was found to have a strong influence on drilling response, but differential pressure did not, contrary to conventional wisdom. The results are compared with other drilling experiments and single-cutter experiments in the literature. Introduction When drilling shale, little or no obvious warning may be given that the pore pressure is abnormally high until a kick is taken as the bit enters a permeable zone below the shale. The very low permeability of the shales (a few nanodarcy1) precludes direct measurement of pore pressure downhole, but the potential serious consequences of a kick demand that the best available estimate of pore pressure be made as soon as a bit enters a shale. In some shales, pore pressure can be inferred from other measurable properties (porosity, resistivity, or sonic) that correlate with the effective stress state of the rock. Studies2,3 have shown that in permeable, brittle rocks, the rate of penetration (ROP) is independent of the absolute value of the BHP but depends on the differential pressure. Previous researchers4-7 and field engineers8,9 have concluded that this is also true of shales and that this relationship can be used to estimate the pore pressure from the drilling response. In all the shale work, however, the pore pressure in the rock being drilled was not measured but was inferred either from logs or from experience with permeable rocks. The experiments reported here were undertaken to examine these relationships between pore pressure and drilling response. Vidrine and Benit's9 work on Louisiana shale studied eight wells where pore pressure was derived from shale resistivity. They concluded that drilling rate was affected by differential pressure. Combs8 produced an empirical model after drilling six wells in Louisiana shale. His model relates the drilling rate to the weight on bit (WOB), rotary speed (RS), and bit hydraulics. He concluded that the ROP was dependent on differential pressure, but again the pore pressure was inferred from logs. Combs also suspected that the absolute BHP was influencing the ROP independently of any effects of differential pressure. In fact, the changes in ROP could have been the result of BHP effects only. Drilling responses of Mancos and Catoosa shales have been studied for a range of bits, hydraulics, and muds.4,7,10 Pore pressure was not measured and was assumed to be atmospheric. In these experiments, drilling response variations were assumed to be caused by changes in differential pressure; however, they also could be attributed only to changes in BHP because the pore pressure is assumed to be constant. Current field practice draws on relationships between the pore pressure and other measurable parameters (often porosity). Originally, the only data available were from wireline logs, which could be interpreted off-line after the well had been drilled. Models were developed that allowed pore pressure to be estimated from surface measurements in real time11; refinements to these models were made to account for bit wear.12 More recently, downhole sensors (measurement- and logging-while-drilling) in the drillstring above the bit have improved model accuracy. Most of these models infer pore pressure from shale porosity values computed with observed changes in ROP. One such model is PERT,13,14 which computes pore pressure at the depth of the resistivity and gamma ray sensors in real time by use of formation strength, resistivity, and gamma ray measurements. The model assumes that an overpressured shale has a higher porosity than a similar normally pressured shale. This paper presents results from a program carried out at Schlumberger Cambridge Research (SCR) to investigate the drilling response of shale under various pressure environments with different bit types. The work was undertaken to determine why conventional pore-pressure interpretation algorithms developed for undercompacted shales met with limited success in harder shales, such as those found in the North Sea, and whether drilling models could be developed to interpret pore pressure in these environments. Results are presented from drilling two hard shales (Jurassic-2 and Welsh shales) similar to those found in some areas of the North Sea. The Jurassic-2 shale was tested in two drilling machines. Table 1 gives mineralogy and properties of the shales used. The shales are saturated. (Samples of both shales were recovered from below high-water mark on beaches and therefore spent a large portion of their recent history underwater. Laboratory measurements also showed that the shales were fully saturated to within the accuracy of the porosity measurements.) The experiments were carried out in the SCR Drillig Test Machine (DTM)15 and the SCR Small Drilling Machine (SDM). The DTM uses 216-mm [8 1/2-in.] -diameter milled-tooth bits to drill a 600-mm [23.6-in.] -diameter, 1-m [3.3-ft] -long sample, and the SDM drills a 150-mm [5.9-in.] -diameter, 200-mm [7.9-in.] -long sample with an 80-mm [3 1/8-in.] -diameter milled-tooth bit. The results are compared with other mechanical properties in the Discussion section. Experimental Procedures Table 2 gives the details of the...Keywords
This publication has 9 references indexed in Scilit:
- Single Cutter Testing – A Key for Pdc Bit Development1987
- Advanced Techniques for Laboratory Full-Scale Drilling Tests1986
- Pore Pressure and Porosity From MWD Measurements1986
- Effects of Selected Mud Properties on Rate of Penetration in Full-Scale Shale Drilling Simulations1985
- Hard Rock Drilling Problems Explained by Hard Rock Pressure Plots1983
- A transient laboratory method for determining the hydraulic properties of ‘tight’ rocks—II. ApplicationInternational Journal of Rock Mechanics and Mining Sciences, 1981
- Prediction Of Pore Pressure From Penetration Rate1968
- Laboratory Study of Effect of Overburden, Formation and Mud Column Pressures on Drilling Rate of Permeable FormationsTransactions of the AIME, 1959
- Effect of Pressure on Rock DrillabilityTransactions of the AIME, 1958