Identifying the Bad Guy in a Lineup Using Confidence Judgments Under Deadline Pressure
- 28 August 2012
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Psychological Science
- Vol. 23 (10) , 1208-1214
Abstract
Eyewitness-identification tests often culminate in witnesses not picking the culprit or identifying innocent suspects. We tested a radical alternative to the traditional lineup procedure used in such tests. Rather than making a positive identification, witnesses made confidence judgments under a short deadline about whether each lineup member was the culprit. We compared this deadline procedure with the traditional sequential-lineup procedure in three experiments with retention intervals ranging from 5 min to 1 week. A classification algorithm that identified confidence criteria that optimally discriminated accurate from inaccurate decisions revealed that decision accuracy was 24% to 66% higher under the deadline procedure than under the traditional procedure. Confidence profiles across lineup stimuli were more informative than were identification decisions about the likelihood that an individual witness recognized the culprit or correctly recognized that the culprit was not present. Large differences between the maximum and the next-highest confidence value signaled very high accuracy. Future support for this procedure across varied conditions would highlight a viable alternative to the problematic lineup procedures that have traditionally been used by law enforcement.Keywords
This publication has 31 references indexed in Scilit:
- Eyewitness IdentificationCurrent Directions in Psychological Science, 2011
- Eyewitness identification testsLegal and Criminological Psychology, 2010
- On the diagnosticity of multiple-witness identifications.Law and Human Behavior, 2008
- Eyewitness confidence and latency: Indices of memory processes not just markers of accuracyApplied Cognitive Psychology, 2008
- Memory distortion in eyewitnesses: a meta-analysis of the post-identification feedback effectApplied Cognitive Psychology, 2006
- Uses and abuses of eyewitness identification confidenceLegal and Criminological Psychology, 2006
- Eyewitness Identification Accuracy and Response Latency.Law and Human Behavior, 2006
- A Re-examination of the Effects of Biased Lineup Instructions in Eyewitness Identification.Law and Human Behavior, 2005
- Processing speed and mental retardation: Deadline procedures indicate fixed and adjustable limitationsMemory & Cognition, 1990
- Strength theory and confidence ratings in recall.Psychological Review, 1971