Assessment of Regulatory Compliance Testing for Vitamin D in Infant Formula—Impact of Delegated Regulation (EU) 2019/828
Authors:
- Donald L GillilandDGDonald L Gilliland
- Brendon D GillBGBrendon D Gill
- Roger C KisslingRKRoger C Kissling
- Dustin E StarkeyDSDustin E Starkey
- Harvey E IndykHIHarvey E Indyk
- Adrienne McMahonAMAdrienne McMahon
- Arnold P BroekABArnold P Broek
- Martine P van GoolMGMartine P van Gool
- Hans M M CruijsenHCHans M M Cruijsen
- Erik J M KoningsEKErik J M Konings
- Esther Campos-GimenezECEsther Campos-Gimenez
- 23 May 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Journal of AOAC INTERNATIONAL
- Vol. 105 (5) , 1360-1366
Abstract
Since the publication of Standard Method Performance Requirements (SMPR®) for vitamin D in infant formula (SMPR 2011.004) by AOAC INTERNATIONAL, revised vitamin D limits have been recommended by the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) for infant formula and adopted in Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2019/828. The vitamin D range introduced, 2–2.5 μg/100 kcal, is significantly narrower than previous limits specified by Codex Standard 72–1981 and requires lower method reproducibility metrics to adequately assess regulatory compliance. The narrower limits for vitamin D present a significant challenge for current-generation reference analytical methods that comply with SMPR 2011.004. We evaluate the impact of Delegated Regulation (EU) 2019/828 on the demonstrated performance of AOAC 2016.05/ISO 20636:2018 to assess the likelihood that vitamin D results produced by the method would be found outside the EU limits when testing infant formula that is compliant as manufactured. AOAC 2016.05/ISO 20636:2018, specifically data generated during multi-laboratory study, was used as a basis for statistical evaluation of the impact of the narrower EU vitamin D limits. The review of AOAC 2016.05/ISO 20636:2018 method performance against the vitamin D regulatory range introduced in (EU) 2019/828 indicates methods capable of performing in alignment with SMPR 2011.004 are likely to produce results that fail to meet EU requirements. Our assessment illustrates the high probability that a well-manufactured product with vitamin D levels within the EU regulatory range would fail to meet the regulatory requirements due to analytical method variability when tested using fit-for-purpose methods. Further, required method performance cannot be expected with the future development of new methods. To avoid this, consideration should be given to aligning proposed regulatory limits with method performance metrics of current-generation compendial methods. Current, state-of-the-art methods cannot consistently verify infant formula product compliance for vitamin D in accordance with (EU) 2019/828.Keywords
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- Challenge to evaluate regulatory compliance for nutrients in infant formulas with current state-of-the-art analytical reference methodsFood Control, 2021
- Recent Advances in the Analysis of Vitamin D and Its Metabolites in Food MatricesSeparations, 2020
- Differential Thermal Isomerization: Its Role in the Analysis of Vitamin D3 in FoodsJournal of AOAC INTERNATIONAL, 2020
- Analysis of Vitamin D2 and Vitamin D3 in Infant and Adult Nutritional Formulas by Liquid Chromatography-Tandem Mass Spectrometry: A Multilaboratory Testing StudyJournal of AOAC INTERNATIONAL, 2018
- Development of Vitamin D Determination in Infant Formula by Column-Switching HPLC with UV DetectorFood Science of Animal Resources, 2012
- Simultaneous Determination of Vitamins D2 and D3 by LC-MS/MS in Infant Formula and Adult Nutritionals: First Action 2011.13Journal of AOAC INTERNATIONAL, 2012
- A rapid analytical method for cholecalciferol (vitamin D3) in fortified infant formula, milk and milk powder using Diels–Alder derivatisation and liquid chromatography–tandem mass spectrometric detectionAnalytical and Bioanalytical Chemistry, 2012
- The Horwitz Ratio (HorRat): A Useful Index of Method Performance with Respect to PrecisionJournal of AOAC INTERNATIONAL, 2006
- Simultaneous quantification of Vitamins A, D3 and E in fortified infant formulae by liquid chromatography–mass spectrometryJournal of Chromatography A, 2004
- Harmonized guidelines for single-laboratory validation of methods of analysis (IUPAC Technical Report)Pure and Applied Chemistry, 2002