Aligning agri-environmental subsidies and environmental needs: a comparative analysis between the US and EU
Authors:
- Sofia BiffiSBSofia Biffi
- Rebecca TraldiRTRebecca Traldi
- Bart CrezeeBCBart Crezee
- Michael BeckmannMBMichael Beckmann
- Lukas EgliLELukas Egli
- Dietrich Epp SchmidtDSDietrich Epp Schmidt
- Nicole MotzerNMNicole Motzer
- Murat OkumahMOMurat Okumah
- Ralf SeppeltRSRalf Seppelt
- Eleonore Louise SlabbertESEleonore Louise Slabbert
- Kate TiedemanKTKate Tiedeman
- Haoluan WangHWHaoluan Wang
Open Access
- 1 May 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by IOP Publishing in Environmental Research Letters
- Vol. 16 (5) , 054067
Abstract
The global recognition of modern agricultural practices’ impact on the environment has fuelled policy responses to ameliorate environmental degradation in agricultural landscapes. In the US and the EU, agri-environmental subsidies (AES) promote widespread adoption of sustainable practices by compensating farmers who voluntarily implement them on working farmland. Previous studies, however, have suggested limitations of their spatial targeting, with funds not allocated towards areas of the greatest environmental need. We analysed AES in the US and EU—specifically through the Environmental Quality Incentives Program (EQIP) and selected measures of the European Agricultural Fund for Rural Development (EAFRD)—to identify if AES are going where they are most needed to achieve environmental goals, using a set of environmental need indicators, socio-economic variables moderating allocation patterns, and contextual variables describing agricultural systems. Using linear mixed models and linear models we explored the associations among AES allocation and these predictors at different scales. We found that higher AES spending was associated with areas of low soil organic carbon and high greenhouse gas emissions both in the US and EU, and nitrogen surplus in the EU. More so than successes, however, clear mismatches of funding and environmental need emerged—AES allocation did not successfully target areas of highest water stress, biodiversity loss, soil erosion, and nutrient runoff. Socio-economic and agricultural context variables may explain some of these mismatches; we show that AES were allocated to areas with higher proportions of female producers in the EU but not in the US, where funds were directed towards areas with less tenant farmers. Moreover, we suggest that the potential for AES to remediate environmental issues may be curtailed by limited participation in intensive agricultural landscapes. These findings can help inform refinements to EQIP and EAFRD allocation mechanisms and identify opportunities for improving future targeting of AES spending.Keywords
Funding Information
- National Science Foundation (1828910)
- Helmholtz Association (VH-KO-613)
- Horizon 2020 Framework Programme (817501)
This publication has 93 references indexed in Scilit:
- Farmers and conservation programs: Explaining differences in Environmental Quality Incentives Program applications between statesJournal of Soil and Water Conservation, 2013
- Use of conservation practices by women farmers in the Northeastern United StatesRenewable Agriculture and Food Systems, 2012
- Reforming Agricultural Nonpoint Pollution Policy in an Increasingly Budget-Constrained EnvironmentEnvironmental Science & Technology, 2012
- Impacts of Decoupled Agricultural Support on Farm Structure, Biodiversity and Landscape Mosaic: Some EU ResultsJournal of Agricultural Economics, 2009
- Effects of agri-environment schemes in a long-term ecological time seriesAgriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 2009
- Agri-environmental policies in the EU and United States: A comparisonEcological Economics, 2008
- Nutrient losses from manure and fertilizer applications as impacted by time to first runoff eventEnvironmental Pollution, 2007
- Impacts of Waste from Concentrated Animal Feeding Operations on Water QualityEnvironmental Health Perspectives, 2007
- High‐resolution fields of global runoff combining observed river discharge and simulated water balancesGlobal Biogeochemical Cycles, 2002
- Land Tenure and the Adoption of Conservation PracticesAmerican Journal of Agricultural Economics, 2000