The Association between the Percentage of Female Law Enforcement Officers and Rape Report, Clearance, and Arrest Rates: A Spatiotemporal Analysis of California
Authors:
- 11 September 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Interpersonal Violence
- Vol. 39 (1-2) , 157-183
Abstract
Rape is an underreported violent crime that frequently remains uncleared (open) in the legal system. Rape disproportionately affects women, with 91% of rape victim-survivors estimated to be female. However, law enforcement agencies, the entry point into the criminal justice system, are predominantly comprised of male officers. According to the theory of representative bureaucracy, groups with greater representation in a bureaucratic system are more likely to have their interests protected. This study aims to determine if California law enforcement agencies with a higher percentage of female officers are more likely to have higher rates of rape reporting, clearances, and arrests. No previous study has examined this relationship using statewide data. Crimes and Clearances, Monthly Arrest and Citation Register, and Uniform Crime Reporting data for California (2013–2016) were aggregated into 499 Law Enforcement Reporting Areas (LERA). Bayesian space-time Poisson regressions controlling for LERA demographics and crime produced scaled relative rates for three outcomes: (a) rape report rate: number of reports relative to population ages 18+; (b) rape clearance rate: number of clearances relative to reports; and (c) rape arrest rate: number of arrests for rape relative to reports. A 5% increase in the percentage of female officers within an agency was associated with a 6.2% increase in the rape report rate (ARR: 1.062, 95% credible interval (CI) [1.048, 1.077]), a 2.9% decrease in the clearance rate (ARR: 0.971 95% CI [0.950, 0.993]), and no change in the rape arrest rates (ARR: 1.010; 95% CI [0.981, 1.039]) across all LERA. Thus, increased female officer representation was associated with an increase in rape reporting rates but associated with a decrease in rape clearance rates. The theory of representative bureaucracy was only partially supported, and these relationships may not be causal. The quantity of rape reports received by an agency, employment and promotion practices of agencies, and victim-survivor’s attitudes toward officer’s gender should also be considered.Keywords
This publication has 53 references indexed in Scilit:
- Police Decision Making in Sexual Assault CasesJournal of Interpersonal Violence, 2012
- Rape: Too Hard to Report and Too Easy to Discredit VictimsViolence Against Women, 2010
- Strength in numbers? A test of Kanter's theory of tokenismJournal of Criminal Justice, 2010
- An Ecological Model of the Impact of Sexual Assault On Women's Mental HealthTrauma, Violence, & Abuse, 2009
- Making RankPolice Quarterly, 2008
- Gender, Representative Bureaucracy, and Law Enforcement: The Case of Sexual AssaultPublic Administration Review, 2006
- Is Disclosure of Childhood Rape Associated with Mental Health Outcome? Results from the National Women’s StudyChild Maltreatment, 2004
- Race, Ethnicity and the Female Cop: Differential Patterns of RepresentationJournal of Urban Affairs, 2001
- Predicting type of sexual assault case closure from victim, suspect, and case characteristicsJournal of Criminal Justice, 2000
- A Computer Movie Simulating Urban Growth in the Detroit RegionEconomic Geography, 1970