Identified versus Statistical Lives

Author:
  • DBDan W. Brock
    Dan W. Brock

Abstract
This chapter introduces and briefly evaluates several arguments commonly thought to support the moral importance of the distinction between statistical and identified lives in the context of saving lives in health care, many of which frequently appear in the literature. It argues that none of them succeeds in doing that. It concludes that when, but only when, a morally important principle like priority to the worse off maps onto the identified/statistical difference, then the identified/statistical difference is morally important—but that is because of the other principle—in this case, priority to the worse off—not the difference between identified and statistical lives