Evaluation of Accuracy and Precision of the Sound-Recorder-Based Point-Counts Applied in Forests and Open Areas in Two Locations Situated in a Temperate and Tropical Regions
Open Access
Abstract
The point-count method is one of the most popular techniques for surveying birds. However, the accuracy and precision of this method may vary across various environments and geographical regions. We conducted sound-recorder-based point-counts to examine the accuracy and precision of the method for bird biodiversity estimation as a function of geographical region, habitat type and the time of day at which the survey began. In temperate (Poland) and tropical (Cameroon) regions, we recorded soundscapes on two successive mornings at 36 recording sites (18 in each location). At each site, we analyzed three 5-min surveys per day. We found no differences in the accuracy and precision of the method between regions and habitats. The accuracy was significantly greater at sunrise than during later surveys. The similarity of the bird assemblages detected by different surveys did not differ between regions or habitats. However, the bird communities described at the same time of day were significantly more similar to each other than those detected by surveys conducted at different times. The point-count method provided statistically indistinguishable estimates of bird biodiversity in different geographical regions and habitats. However, our results highlight two weaknesses of the method: low accuracy (41–54%), which limits the usefulness of a single survey in understanding bird–environment relationships, and changes in accuracy throughout the day, which may result in the misinterpretation of the status of bird populations.Keywords
Funding Information
- Ministerstwo Edukacji i Nauki (IP2014 005073)
- Narodowe Centrum Nauki (2015/17/B/NZ8/02347, 2019/35/D/NZ8/04416)
This publication has 41 references indexed in Scilit:
- Point count duration: five minutes are usually sufficient to model the distribution of bird species and to study the structure of communities for a French landscapeJournal of Ornithology, 2011
- Humans versus autonomous recording units: a comparison of point-count resultsJournal of Field Ornithology, 2009
- Testing the importance of auditory detections in avian point countsJournal of Field Ornithology, 2009
- Using soundscape recordings to estimate bird species abundance, richness, and compositionJournal of Field Ornithology, 2009
- Imperfect detection and its consequences for monitoring for conservationCommunity Ecology, 2008
- Absent or undetected? Effects of non-detection of species occurrence on wildlife–habitat modelsBiological Conservation, 2004
- Refining the Use of Point Counts at the Scale of Individual Points in Studies of Bird-Habitat RelationshipsJournal of Avian Biology, 1999
- Influence of Point Count Length and Repeated Visits on Habitat Model PerformanceThe Journal of Wildlife Management, 1999
- Reversal of breeding season by lowland birds at higher altitudes in western CameroonIbis, 1992
- Estimating numbers of birds by point counts: how long should counts last?Bird Study, 1984