A Comparison of Reliability and Resource Utilization of Radiation Fault Tolerance Mechanisms in Spaceborne Electronic Systems
Open Access
Abstract
The advent of the New Space Era has significantly accelerated the development of space equipment systems using commercial off-the-shelf components. Field Programmable Gate Arrays are increasingly favored for their ability to be easily modified, which substantially reduces both development time and costs. However, their high susceptibility to space radiation poses a considerable risk of mission failure, potentially compromising system reliability in harsh space environments. To mitigate this vulnerability, the implementation of fault-tolerant mechanisms is essential. In this study, we applied eight distinct fault-tolerant mechanisms to various circuits and conducted a comparative analysis between two different categories: hardware redundancy and informational redundancy. This comparison was based on consistent criteria, specifically the Architectural Vulnerability Factor and resource consumption. Utilizing statistical fault injection tests and specialized software, we quantitatively measured structural vulnerability, power consumption, delay, and area. The results revealed that while the Hamming Code achieved the lowest structural vulnerability, it resulted in approximately fourfold increases in resource consumption. Conversely, Triple Modular Redundancy provided high reliability with relatively minimal resource usage. This research elucidates the trade-offs between reliability and resource overhead among different fault-tolerant mechanisms, highlighting the critical importance of selecting appropriate mechanisms based on system requirements to optimize the balance between reliability and resource utilization. Our analysis offers new insights essential for optimizing fault-tolerant mechanisms in space applications. Future work should explore more complex circuit architectures and diverse fault models to refine the selection criteria for fault-tolerant mechanisms tailored to real-world space missions.Keywords
Funding Information
- GRRC Korea Aerospace University (2023-B02, 2022K1A3A1A2001493)
- National Research Foundation of Korea (2023-B02, 2022K1A3A1A2001493)
This publication has 46 references indexed in Scilit:
- Analyzing Bit Error Propagation in Multilayer Communication Networks: Codebook Method to Combine TMR and Hamming2024
- Hardware-Efficient FPGA-Based Approximate Multipliers for Error-Tolerant Computing2022
- Multilayer radiation shield for satellite electronic components protectionScientific Reports, 2021
- Optimization of Energy and Area of a Randshift: Fault-Tolerant Technique using FPGA design flow2021
- FPGA-Based Multi-Level Approximate Multipliers for High-Performance Error-Resilient ApplicationsIEEE Access, 2020
- From new space to big space: How commercial space dream is becoming a realityActa Astronautica, 2020
- Determining the necessity of fault tolerance techniques in FPGA devices for space missionsMicroprocessors and Microsystems, 2018
- Improved Performance of Error Controlling Codes Using Pass Transistor LogicCircuits, Systems, and Signal Processing, 2017
- DMR+: An efficient alternative to TMR to protect registers in Xilinx FPGAsMicroelectronics Reliability, 2016
- Design methodology adopting normalized power-delay-and-area product (N-PDAP) for digital-circuit optimizationCurrent Applied Physics, 2004