Resource Utilization and Cost-Effectiveness of Counselor- vs. Provider-Based Rapid Point-of-Care HIV Screening in the Emergency Department
Open Access
- 12 October 2011
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 6 (10) , e25575
Abstract
Routine HIV screening in emergency department (ED) settings may require dedicated personnel. We evaluated the outcomes, costs and cost-effectiveness of HIV screening when offered by either a member of the ED staff or by an HIV counselor. We employed a mathematical model to extend data obtained from a randomized clinical trial of provider- vs. counselor-based HIV screening in the ED. We compared the downstream survival, costs, and cost-effectiveness of three HIV screening modalities: 1) no screening program; 2) an ED provider-based program; and 3) an HIV counselor-based program. Trial arm-specific data were used for test offer and acceptance rates (provider offer 36%, acceptance 75%; counselor offer 80%, acceptance 71%). Undiagnosed HIV prevalence (0.4%) and linkage to care rates (80%) were assumed to be equal between the screening modalities. Personnel costs were derived from trial-based resource utilization data. We examined the generalizability of results by conducting sensitivity analyses on offer and acceptance rates, undetected HIV prevalence, and costs. Estimated HIV screening costs in the provider and counselor arms averaged $8.10 and $31.00 per result received. The Provider strategy (compared to no screening) had an incremental cost-effectiveness ratio of $58,700/quality-adjusted life year (QALY) and the Counselor strategy (compared to the Provider strategy) had an incremental cost-effectiveness ratio of $64,500/QALY. Results were sensitive to the relative offer and acceptance rates by strategy and the capacity of providers to target-screen, but were robust to changes in undiagnosed HIV prevalence and programmatic costs. The cost-effectiveness of provider-based HIV screening in an emergency department setting compares favorably to other US screening programs. Despite its additional cost, counselor-based screening delivers just as much return on investment as provider based-screening. Investment in dedicated HIV screening personnel is justified in situations where ED staff resources may be insufficient to provide comprehensive, sustainable screening services.Keywords
This publication has 41 references indexed in Scilit:
- Emergency Provider Attitudes and Barriers to Universal HIV Testing in the Emergency DepartmentThe Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2012
- Counselor- Versus Provider-Based HIV Screening in the Emergency Department: Results From the Universal Screening for HIV Infection in the Emergency Room (USHER) Randomized Controlled TrialAnnals of Emergency Medicine, 2011
- Expanded HIV Screening in the United States: What Will It Cost Government Discretionary and Entitlement Programs? A Budget Impact AnalysisValue in Health, 2010
- Factors Associated with Refusal of Rapid HIV Testing in an Emergency DepartmentAIDS and Behavior, 2010
- Cost of Rapid HIV Testing at 45 U.S. HospitalsAIDS Patient Care and STDs, 2010
- Racial and Sex Disparities in Life Expectancy Losses among HIV‐Infected Persons in the United States: Impact of Risk Behavior, Late Initiation, and Early Discontinuation of Antiretroviral TherapyClinical Infectious Diseases, 2009
- Rapid HIV testing program implementation: lessons from the emergency departmentInternational Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2009
- Unsafe Sex, Substance Abuse, and Domestic Violence: How Do Recently Trained Obstetricians–Gynecologists Fare at Lifestyle Risk Assessment and Counseling on STD Prevention?Preventive Medicine, 2002
- The Cost Effectiveness of Combination Antiretroviral Therapy for HIV DiseaseNew England Journal of Medicine, 2001
- Why Doctors Have Difficulty With Sex HistoriesSouthern Medical Journal, 1990