What is the most relevant standard of success in assisted reproduction?

Authors:
  • FUFrançoise Urner
    Françoise Urner
  • ACAlain Chanson
    Alain Chanson
  • MPMarie-Pierre Primi
    Marie-Pierre Primi
  • DWDaniel Wirthner
    Daniel Wirthner
  • ASAlfred Senn
    Alfred Senn

Abstract
National and international registries are essential tools for establishing new standards and comparing success rates, but they do not take into account the total pregnancy/delivery rate per oocyte recovery. In Switzerland and Germany, because of legal constraints, a maximum of three two-pronuclear zygotes are allocated for transfer whereas all the supernumerary pronuclear zygotes are immediately cryopreserved, preventing selection of the transferred embryos. We report on a 10 years' experience (1993–2002) of our centre which performs transfers of unselected embryos and cryopreservation at the two-pronuclear zygote stage. As ∼30% of all deliveries are from cryo cycles, it is essential to take into account the contribution of the cryo transfers, and we propose therefore to evaluate, as a measure of IVF performance, the cumulated delivery rate per oocyte pick-up. This delivery rate is broken down further into the cumulated singleton delivery rate (CUSIDERA) and the cumulated twin delivery rate (CUTWIDERA). The sum (S) of these two rates is a measure of efficacy while the ratio CUTWIDERA/S as a percentage is a measure of safety of IVF treatments. Using these new indexes, the average 10 year efficacy and safety of our IVF programme were 26 and 19%, respectively. Both CUSIDERA and CUTWIDERA can be calculated easily in any clinical situation and yield useful parameters for patient counselling and internal/external benchmarking purposes.

This publication has 14 references indexed in Scilit: