Neoliberal growth vs food system democratization: narrative analysis of Canadian federal and civil society agri-food policy
Open Access
- 5 December 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Agriculture and Human Values
- Vol. 42 (2) , 923-943
Abstract
Narratives inform policymaking by building consensus, stabilizing our shared beliefs, and legitimizing our assumptions (Roe 1992, 1994). This research applies narrative policy analysis to identify and compare the dominant agriculture and food (agri-food) narratives of Canadian federal government and civil society policy over time. It aims to understand and compare what narratives are driving the agri-food policy priorities of each group, with particular attention to how policy narratives address social and environmental goals. This analysis documents and confirms a Neoliberal Techno-optimist Growth Narrative as the dominant narrative in federal Canadian Agriculture and Agri-food Canada (AAFC) policy between 1986 and 2019. Over a similar period, civil society has adopted narratives that prioritize localization and democratization of the food system as well as food security. While the neoliberal priorities of market expansion and competitiveness are the focus within federal narratives, civil society concerns related to the social and environmental costs of economic efficiency, including reduced farmer livelihoods, environmental degradation, and loss of community decision-making capacity, have received marginal attention from federal policy. We discuss how the Neoliberal Techno-optimist Growth Narrative imposes structural barriers on the pursuit of environmental and social goals by establishing a hierarchy of goals whereby environmental/social goals can only be pursued to the extent that they contribute to economic growth and by promoting a techno-optimist approach. As such, the dominant Neoliberal Techno-optimist Growth Narrative stabilizes two contested assumptions: (1) economic growth through liberalized trade is the best approach to achieve societal wellbeing, and (2) that technological innovation will sufficiently address environmental pressures.Keywords
Funding Information
- Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada (970-2021-1015)
- Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada (767-2023-1640)
This publication has 129 references indexed in Scilit:
- Replacing humans with machines: a historical look at technology politics in California agricultureAgriculture and Human Values, 2022
- Why is ecological sustainability so difficult to achieve? An in‐context discussion of conceptual barriersSustainable Development, 2022
- New but for whom? Discourses of innovation in precision agricultureAgriculture and Human Values, 2021
- Who drives the digital revolution in agriculture? A review of supply‐side trends, players and challengesApplied Economic Perspectives and Policy, 2021
- Smart Farming Technologies – Description, Taxonomy and Economic Impact2017
- A quantitative analysis of food movement convergence in four Canadian provincesAgriculture and Human Values, 2017
- Green Growth Strategies in Agriculture in OECD Countries2016
- Alternative economic strategies and the technology treadmill: Beginning vegetable farmers in IowaEconomic Anthropology, 2016
- Investor ownership or social investment? Changing farmland ownership in Saskatchewan, CanadaAgriculture and Human Values, 2016
- Towards a third food regime: behind the transformationAgriculture and Human Values, 2009