"Moral Conviction" plus "Joint Sanctions": The Judgment-"Moral Conviction" plus "Joint Sanctions": The Judgmentdefaulter Blacklist System in China defaulter Blacklist System in China
This article examines China's judgment-defaulter blacklist system, which serves as the foundation for the broader social credit system. It highlights how this system uses a strategic combination of "moral conviction" and "joint sanctions" to address the judiciary's failure in enforcing judgments and the shortcomings of traditional legal methods. Operating parallel to the existing legal framework, the blacklist can impose double penalties on those identified as discredited judgment defaulters. Furthermore, the joint sanctions are influenced by an ancient Legalism principle, leading to potential violations of fundamental legal principles in contemporary Chinese law. This raises concerns about the legality, reasonableness, and due process of the sanctions imposed. As the blacklist system's application grows, it risks undermining the integrity of the legal system. In light of the Chinese national legislature's review of the Civil Compulsory Enforcement Law, the article argues for the abolition of the joint sanction mechanism and advocates for enforcement measures that align with the rule of law, ensuring a fair and just legal framework.