Comparison of DNA- and RNA-Based Methods for Detection of TruncatingBRCA1 Mutations
- 27 June 2002
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Human Mutation
- Vol. 20 (1) , 65-73
Abstract
A number of methods are used for mutational analysis of BRCA1, a large multi‐exon gene. A comparison was made of five methods to detect mutations generating premature stop codons that are predicted to result in synthesis of a truncated protein in BRCA1. These included four DNA‐based methods: two‐dimensional gene scanning (TDGS), denaturing high performance liquid chromatography (DHPLC), enzymatic mutation detection (EMD), and single strand conformation polymorphism analysis (SSCP) and an RNA/DNA‐based protein truncation test (PTT) with and without complementary 5′ sequencing. DNA and RNA samples isolated from 21 coded lymphoblastoid cell line samples were tested. These specimens had previously been analyzed by direct automated DNA sequencing, considered to be the optimum method for mutation detection. The set of 21 cell lines included 14 samples with 13 unique frameshift or nonsense mutations, three samples with two unique splice site mutations, and four samples without deleterious mutations. The present study focused on the detection of protein‐truncating mutations, those that have been reported most often to be disease‐causing alterations that segregate with cancer in families. PTT with complementary 5′ sequencing correctly identified all 15 deleterious mutations. Not surprisingly, the DNA‐based techniques did not detect a deletion of exon 22. EMD and DHPLC identified all of the mutations with the exception of the exon 22 deletion. Two mutations were initially missed by TDGS, but could be detected after slight changes in the test design, and five truncating mutations were missed by SSCP. It will continue to be important to use complementary methods for mutational analysis.Keywords
This publication has 35 references indexed in Scilit:
- The R71GBRCA1is a founder Spanish mutation and leads to aberrant splicing of the transcriptHuman Mutation, 2001
- Founder Mutations in the BRCA1 Gene in Polish Families with Breast-Ovarian CancerThe American Journal of Human Genetics, 2000
- The protein truncation test: A reviewHuman Mutation, 1999
- Casein Kinase 2 Binds to and Phosphorylates BRCA1Biochemical and Biophysical Research Communications, 1999
- Design and application of 2-D DGGE-based gene mutational scanning testsGenetic Analysis: Biomolecular Engineering, 1999
- A Simple System for Automated Two-Dimensional Electrophoresis: Applications to Genetic TestingGenetic Testing, 1998
- Heteroduplex and protein truncation analysis of the BRCA1 185delAG mutationHuman Genetics, 1996
- Mutational scanning of large genes by extensive PCR multiplexing and two-dimensional electrophoresis: application to the RB1 geneHuman Molecular Genetics, 1996
- Detection of 81 of 81 Known Mouse β-Globin Promoter Mutations with T4 Endonuclease VII—The EMC MethodGenomics, 1996
- Endonuclease VII of Phage T4 Triggers Mismatch Correction in VitroJournal of Molecular Biology, 1993