A theoretical analysis of the barriers and facilitators to the implementation of school-based physical activity policies in Canada: a mixed methods scoping review
Open Access
- 27 March 2017
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Springer Nature in Implementation Science
- Vol. 12 (1) , 41
Abstract
Given the potential impact school-based daily physical activity (DPA) policies can have on the health outcomes of Canadian children, it is surprising that such little research has examined the implementation and student-level effectiveness of these policies, and that even less have used theory to understand the barriers and facilitators affecting uptake of this policy by teachers. This review descriptively summarizes the implementation status, approaches used to implement DPA, and the effectiveness of DPA at increasing the physical activity of children at school. In addition, the Theoretical Domains Framework (TDF) was used to explore the barriers and facilitators to DPA implementation. A scoping review of English articles using ERIC, CINAHL, and Google Scholar (2005 to 2016) was conducted. Only studies that evaluated the implementation and/or student-level effectiveness of DPA policies in Canadian elementary schools were included. Only articles that examined DPA implementation barriers and facilitators by teachers, principals, and/or administration were eligible for the TDF analysis. Data on study characteristics and major findings regarding implementation status, implementation approach used, and impact on student’s physical activity were extracted and were summarized descriptively, including study quality indicators. Two coders extracted and categorized implementation barriers and facilitators into TDF domains. The search resulted in 66 articles being retrieved and 38 being excluded for not meeting the eligibility criteria, leaving 15 eligible for review (10 of which examined barriers and facilitators to implementation from DPA deliverers’ perspective). Eleven of 15 studies examined the Ontario DPA policy, and 2 studies were from both Alberta and British Columbia. Thirteen studies examined implementation, and only two examined effectiveness. DPA implementation status, approaches to delivery, and effectiveness on student’s PA levels are inconsistent across the three provinces. A total of 203 barriers/facilitators were extracted across the ten implementation studies, most of which related to the environmental context and resources (ECR; n = 86; 37.4%), beliefs about consequences (n = 41; 17.8%), and social influences (n = 36; 15.7%) TDF domains. With the limited research examining the DPA policy in Canada, the current status and approaches used to implement DPA and the student-level effectiveness is not well understood; however, this review revealed that DPA deliverers often report many barriers to DPA implementation. Most importantly, in conducting a TDF-based analysis of the barriers/facilitators affecting implementation, this review provides a theoretical basis by which researchers and policy-makers can design interventions to better target these problems in the future. A protocol for this review was not registered.Keywords
This publication has 52 references indexed in Scilit:
- What is actually measured in process evaluations for worksite health promotion programs: a systematic reviewBMC Public Health, 2013
- From policy to practice: implementation of physical activity and food policies in schoolsInternational Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity, 2013
- Validation of the theoretical domains framework for use in behaviour change and implementation researchImplementation Science, 2012
- Scoping studies: advancing the methodologyImplementation Science, 2010
- A multi-level examination of school programs, policies and resources associated with physical activity among elementary school youth in the PLAY-ON studyInternational Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity, 2010
- Systematic review of the health benefits of physical activity and fitness in school-aged children and youthInternational Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity, 2010
- The influence of exercise and BMI on injuries and illnesses in overweight and obese adults: a randomized control trialInternational Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity, 2010
- Implementation of Texas Senate Bill 19 to Increase Physical Activity in Elementary SchoolsJournal of Public Health Policy, 2009
- Implementation Matters: A Review of Research on the Influence of Implementation on Program Outcomes and the Factors Affecting ImplementationAmerican Journal of Community Psychology, 2008
- A Process for Systematically Reviewing the Literature: Providing the Research Evidence for Public Health Nursing InterventionsWorldviews on Evidence-Based Nursing, 2004