Comparative Analysis of Engineering Carbonation Model Extensions to Account for Pre-Existing Cracks
Open Access
- 12 September 2023
- Vol. 16 (18) , 6177
Abstract
Cracks in reinforced concrete structures can accelerate the local depassivation of reinforcement due to carbonation. Different approaches have been proposed to account for pre-existing cracks within engineering models to predict the carbonation depth. In this study, we provide a detailed comparative analysis of different extensions available for the fib carbonation model to account for cracks, viz., crack influence factor (CIF) approaches, a diffusion-based model and the crack depth adaption. The model extensions are first validated against a dataset of lab data collected from the literature and additional experiments performed as the part of this study. The CIF approaches achieved the highest accuracy for the carbonation depth prediction when compared against lab data. The diffusion-based model was inaccurate for low concentrations. The crack depth adaption provides overly conservative results. No model was found to be best performing, and large scatter was observed between predicted and experimental values. This emphasizes the need for more detailed multi-physics-based models to achieve accurate predictions. For further comparison, service life predictions were conducted for two structural scales, viz., the whole structure and the cracked area. It is concluded that the choice of model extension and the structural scale of analysis have a large influence on predicted probability of failure.
Keywords
Funding Information
- German Federal Ministry for the Environment, Nature Conservation, Nuclear Safety and Consumer Protection (1501617)
This publication has 34 references indexed in Scilit:
- Modeling of the influence of transverse cracking on chloride penetration into concreteCement and Concrete Composites, 2013
- Comparison of carbonation depths measured on in-field exposed existing r.c. structures with predictions made using fib-Model Code 2010Cement and Concrete Composites, 2013
- Influence of Cracking on Carbonation of Cement-Based MaterialsAdvanced Materials Research, 2011
- Effect of crack opening on carbon dioxide penetration in cracked mortar samplesMaterials and Structures, 2008
- Accelerated protocol for measurement of carbonation through a crack surfaceCement and Concrete Research, 2007
- Modeling of the link between microstructure and effective diffusivity of cement pastes using a simplified composite modelCement and Concrete Research, 2007
- Predicting carbonation in early-aged cracked concreteCement and Concrete Research, 2006
- A study on carbonation in concrete structures at existing cracksJournal of the Chinese Institute of Engineers, 2000
- Quantification of the influence of cracks in concrete structures on carbonation and chloride penetrationMagazine of Concrete Research, 1999
- Effect of damage in reinforced concrete on carbonation or chloride penetrationCement and Concrete Research, 1988