Uncertainty Interaction in Software-Intensive Systems: A Community Roadmap
Authors:
- Javier CámaraJCJavier Cámara
- Raffaela MirandolaRMRaffaela Mirandola
- Kenji TeiKTKenji Tei
- Nelly BencomoNBNelly Bencomo
- Matteo CamilliMCMatteo Camilli
- Nicolás CardozoNCNicolás Cardozo
- Ivana DusparicIDIvana Dusparic
- Fuyuki IshikawaFIFuyuki Ishikawa
- Anne KoziolekAKAnne Koziolek
- Livia LestingiLLLivia Lestingi
- Jialong LiJialong Li
- Marin LitoiuMLMarin Litoiu
Open Access
- 9 September 2026
- journal article
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM) in ACM Transactions on Autonomous and Adaptive Systems
Abstract
Despite substantial progress in managing uncertainty in software-intensive systems, existing methods often treat uncertainty sources independently and provide limited support for understanding their combined effects. When multiple uncertainties propagate through system elements and converge at shared variables, models, or decision points, they may interact in ways that alter system behavior, compromise requirements, or invalidate assurance arguments. This challenge, referred to as the uncertainty interaction problem, remains insufficiently understood. This roadmap paper reports the outcomes of the NII Shonan Seminar No. 232 on Uncertainty Interaction in Software-Intensive Systems (UNISON), held in March 2026. It develops a shared conceptual vocabulary for distinguishing uncertainty sources, propagation, confluence, interaction, and relevance; proposes an abstract workflow for identifying, filtering, and assessing relevant uncertainty interactions; and introduces a lifecycle-oriented framework for characterizing and selecting mitigation strategies. Building on these foundations, the paper organizes open challenges into a staged research roadmap spanning conceptual consolidation, reusable methods, engineering integration, validation, tooling, and community adoption. The roadmap provides a common reference point for researchers and practitioners working across software engineering, self-adaptive systems, control, artificial intelligence, formal methods, and assurance.Keywords
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- Surveying uncertainty representation: a unified model for cyber-physical systemsComputing, 2026
- Auto-COP: Adaptation generation in Context-oriented Programming using Reinforcement Learning optionsInformation and Software Technology, 2023
- The uncertainty interaction problem in self-adaptive systemsSoftware and Systems Modeling, 2022
- Uncertainty representation in software models: a surveySoftware and Systems Modeling, 2021
- A Classification Framework of Uncertainty in Architecture-Based Self-Adaptive Systems With Multiple Quality Requirements2017
- Model predictive control for software systems with CobRA2016
- Proactive self-adaptation under uncertainty: a probabilistic model checking approach2015
- DYNAMICO: A Reference Model for Governing Control Objectives and Context Relevance in Self-Adaptive Software Systems2013
- RELAX: a language to address uncertainty in self-adaptive systems requirementRequirements Engineering, 2010
- Deriving specifications from requirements1995